j_garcia Audioholic Jedi Jul 11, 2005 32,531 0 113 Nov 19, 2024 #1 Slow start as expected, a lot of info in that episode. We'll see how it develops, it was interesting enough that I will keep watching. Production value seemed good. Reactions: Trell
Slow start as expected, a lot of info in that episode. We'll see how it develops, it was interesting enough that I will keep watching. Production value seemed good.
isolar8001 Audioholic Field Marshall Jan 11, 2023 1,729 0 36 70 Pittsburgh, Pa. Nov 19, 2024 #2 As a Dune fan (since 1977)....I absolutely hated it. Everything about it screamed cheap drivel....glorified fan fiction. Travis Fimmel was the only good thing about it. Reactions: Trell
As a Dune fan (since 1977)....I absolutely hated it. Everything about it screamed cheap drivel....glorified fan fiction. Travis Fimmel was the only good thing about it.
j_garcia Audioholic Jedi Jul 11, 2005 32,531 0 113 Nov 19, 2024 #3 isolar8001 said: As a Dune fan (since 1977)....I absolutely hated it. Everything about it screamed cheap drivel....glorified fan fiction. Travis Fimmel was the only good thing about it. Click to expand... Seemed to be a lot of mixed reaction to it. We'll see where it goes. It does feel like they are trying too hard and it comes across a bit flat.
isolar8001 said: As a Dune fan (since 1977)....I absolutely hated it. Everything about it screamed cheap drivel....glorified fan fiction. Travis Fimmel was the only good thing about it. Click to expand... Seemed to be a lot of mixed reaction to it. We'll see where it goes. It does feel like they are trying too hard and it comes across a bit flat.
isolar8001 Audioholic Field Marshall Jan 11, 2023 1,729 0 36 70 Pittsburgh, Pa. Nov 19, 2024 #4 j_garcia said: Seemed to be a lot of mixed reaction to it. We'll see where it goes. It does feel like they are trying too hard and it comes across a bit flat. Click to expand... Biggest problem is basing it on one of Frank's sons books....that are truly juvenile compared to the 6 Frank Herbert originals, and as far as I'm concerned...non-canon. I'm pretty sure if Frank were alive and someone told him the setup for this series, he would have strongly objected.
j_garcia said: Seemed to be a lot of mixed reaction to it. We'll see where it goes. It does feel like they are trying too hard and it comes across a bit flat. Click to expand... Biggest problem is basing it on one of Frank's sons books....that are truly juvenile compared to the 6 Frank Herbert originals, and as far as I'm concerned...non-canon. I'm pretty sure if Frank were alive and someone told him the setup for this series, he would have strongly objected.
j_garcia Audioholic Jedi Jul 11, 2005 32,531 0 113 Dec 1, 2024 #5 I am moderately interested still. It has a moment here and there, but basically is like reading the dictionary. Extremely dense and slow moving. It needs to get moving soon though.
I am moderately interested still. It has a moment here and there, but basically is like reading the dictionary. Extremely dense and slow moving. It needs to get moving soon though.
j_garcia Audioholic Jedi Jul 11, 2005 32,531 0 113 Dec 31, 2024 #6 It got much better thankfully. S2 already greenlit before the short season even ended.
davidscott Audioholic Spartan Aug 9, 2018 5,518 0 83 Jan 1, 2025 #7 Haven't watched it yet but as a longtime Dune reader I'm sure I will.
