Desktop PC as 5.1 receiver

T

the caveman

Audioholic Intern
hey guys this will be the last post about my endeavors to avoid using a standard 5.1 surround sound receiver.
my latest scheme is to use the PC console im building as my 5.1 surround sound receiver. The plan is to use a high end PC sound card like
http://www.frys.com/product/5748642?site=sr:SEARCH:MAIN_RSLT_PG
(or better if i can find one) and run the outputs again through my mixer and amps to hopefully give me some sort of sound quality. The only problems i can for see with this plan is no.1 I will probably/defiantly have poorer sound quality than a half decent receiver and no.2 wont i still have the frequency response problems i ran into using the HDMI splitter.
thanks jesse
 
T

timmay8612

Audioholic
I bought the Onkyo 5.1 receiver in my sig for about $40 on ebay. Seems like that would be a far better solution, even if an old school receiver doesn't do HDMI. YMMV of course.
 
Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
Umm...

I think you are running aground on home theater because you come from a professional audio background. General rule of thumb is, these items don't typically mix in the way you want them too. For someone just starting to get into home theater I think it's best to keep professional audio and home audio separate from one another because it will A. simplify things, and B. reduce your costs (as insane as that might sound). By trying to make your professional mixer and amplifiers work with home audio equipment you're effectively limiting your options and increasing costs with specialty items in attempt to make something perform a function that it was intended for.

A PC cannot act as a home theater receiver. In order for a receiver to be a receiver it needs 4 essential parts.

1 - A tuner; typically FM and AM, but may also include Internet Radio, Sirius, or XM radio.

2 - A processor; to decode bitstream surround formats such as Dolby and DTS offerings as well as post processes that include bass management and video processing.

3 - A preamplifier; to control input selection and output level.

4 - An amplifier; powers the speakers in the home theater.

Now the audio card can perform two of these functions, the processing and preamplifier (only partial preamplifier function since it doesn't have more than one input). However this is no good unless you have powered monitors all around or you plan to use 5.1 surround PC speakers.

If you decide to go this route you lose the option to connect additional sources such as video game consules, DVD player, television (satellite or cable), or a Blu-ray player, just to name a few. Basically you're tied into using your computer as your only source for home theater and your speaker selection options will be limited and will be costly for a good arrangement. A budget arrangement would offer sub-par performance.

Let's assume you are able to nab a receiver for around $50-100 that is 5.1 and has on-board Dolby Digital and DTS decoding. Once you have this you're options for speakers are nearly limitless, as most budget oriented speakers will not be tasking for a budget receiver to work with.

So let's keep to the receiver idea and work from there. HDMI switching on a receiver may not be necessary either, so keep that in mind. If your television or display has enough HDMI inputs to support your devices then you don't "need" to have HDMI support on the receiver. If your concern is that you won't get the best sound from a source such as Blu-ray without HDMI I am willing to bet you and many others would not notice a large or any difference between a system connected with traditional SPDIF (optical or coaxial digital) vs. HDMI. I'm not in any way saying there isn't a difference, but the difference isn't huge and it would be difficult to discern without an outstanding sound system.
 
Last edited:
BoredSysAdmin

BoredSysAdmin

Audioholic Slumlord
Seth is right, I'd just like to point to one more problem with using your pc as pro/pro - if you forget to turn-off your amp, while windows is booting up - you might want to wear ear protection since it'll be extremely loud.
 
AcuDefTechGuy

AcuDefTechGuy

Audioholic Jedi
Yeah, I agree. The PC should function only as a media player.

Let the processing be done my a receiver or pre-pro.
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top