My question is why hasn't the seller responded to this post? If Cbinvb is not being honest, then he has plenty of opportunity to offer his response. It seems the buyer got his money back which is good thanks to venmo,
If the seller ghosted him in the process and didn't follow up, and made the buyer have to go through the dispute process, he shouldn't be allowed to post items here.
All we have is one side of the story, but tbh it looks pretty convincing.