Yeah, you can get a dedicated DAP. I just don't see the value in it in the slightest. The majority of the population tends to agree, the sales numbers make that clear. Same for cameras, only the enthusiast has a standalone camera now, and the phone cameras are very good now anyway.
The smart phone really is an incredible invention. Basically a computer and internet in your pocket. I don't actually even talk on my phone very much.
Just because all of those other features are there, it does not detract from the music portion of the phone.
I do agree about the slimy marketing tracking! That is the drawback.
And, I understand the reluctance to move to a smart phone, I was the same way many years ago. Once I bought in, my entire attitude changed.