I have not heard them, but what size room were you auditioning them in and do you know if they were properly positioned? That can have a big impact on some speakers, depending on how they're ported, room boundaries, etc.
Also, will you be using a subwoofer to handle the bass? If you are going to have a sub then the Icons would make more sense perhaps since you liked their mids and highs better so you can have that combined with the better bass from a dedicated subwoofer.