Best Sub Under $600

U

Unregistered

Guest
Hello after several months I have finaly raised enough money to finally finish my surround system with a nice tight sub. I have about $600 to spend and am considering the following products. I listen to music 60% and Movies 40%.

My primary concern is the music as I live in a condex I cannot have huge thumping bass as it will piss off my neighbors. My mains do a decent job of producing bass but ony have 5" drivers and need some help to round them out. Just looking to add some depth to music and movies. Something that goes to at least 28Hz. I definatley don't need the windows to rattle at this time.

I am considering:

Adire Audio Rava
Outlaw Audio Sub
Onix Rocket UFW 10 & ELT SW-10
REL Quake
New Velodyne Digital Drive DSP subs
PSB 5i

I unfortunately cant hear all the subs due to dealers in my area and would consider buying from internet.

Thanks for the suggestions
 
F

Falp

Audioholic Intern
Rel Quake no doubt

For great results with music and movies!
 
JoeE SP9

JoeE SP9

Senior Audioholic
Your neighbors are really gonna' love 28hz at 100db. Seriously, loud sounds below 75-80 hz can carry quite well through walls floors and masonry. I live in a row house; physically a lot like a condo. My neighbors have mentioned that the bass really carries. Consequently I don't play loud music at hours that would be offensive. Before 10AM or after 10PM unless its a weekend. The rest of the time it's "light the fires and smoke the tires". :cool:
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
Those suggestions sound like a great start, really interested in the outlaw but I think it might be a bit to much to handle, I don't think I need a sub that powerful yet. I am going to hear the REL quake and Q150 then I will decide. For some reason I am really interested in the PSB 5i. Several reviewers said it provided smooth blended bass as if it werent present. The bass was not obtrusive but rather filled out the bottom end with tight lows on music and provided thump in movies.

Thanks for all the great suggestions thus far- I will take them all to heart.
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
My vote goes towards the UFW-10, it's the "musical" sub I've heard under $1,500.
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
SVS sounds like a winner but I cannot stomach the thought of having a beer refrigerator in my living room.
 
D

Dr. Anthony

Audioholic Intern
My money is on an SVS

I would go with either the 25-31 PCi or the 20-39 PCi for $525 and $575 respectively. I mesasured 116 db transients and a 109-110 sustained average SPL sweep on a RS soundmeter on my 25-31 PCi. A 27 hz tone kicked out 106 db and sharply declined afterward. We put it head to head with a B&W at over $2000 in every category it played louder. It tromped the polk, and went lower than the ML Descent.

If you want to hold off a bit, SVS is coming out with a 10" box sub in the $400 price range called the PB10-ISD that with a 300 watt amp that will knock your sox off if price is an issue. They will be coming our way in very late october. That is going to make for some incredible combos. :)
 
Rob Babcock

Rob Babcock

Moderator
Dr. Anthony said:
I would go with either the 25-31 PCi or the 20-39 PCi for $525 and $575 respectively. I mesasured 116 db transients and a 109-110 sustained average SPL sweep on a RS soundmeter on my 25-31 PCi. A 27 hz tone kicked out 106 db and sharply declined afterward. We put it head to head with a B&W at over $2000 in every category it played louder. It tromped the polk, and went lower than the ML Descent.
He just said aesthetics ruled out those particular subs- to be most helpful you should read the post first.:rolleyes:

There are several really good ones for under $600. The box SVS have a good repution for HT sound, and you might be able to find a DefTech model in your price range. Many guys I know have also had excellent luck with Hsu's box subs and the Adire Rava sub. The Adire has the 'advantage' of a fully finished enclosure, if appearance is an issue- it's a very attractive sub, available in black or wood finish. It's also sealed, which a lot of people prefer for music. (I like ported subs fine for music, just pointing it out. They make a ported "Rava-on-steroids" called the Dharman, too).
 
D

Dr. Anthony

Audioholic Intern
I find SVS great for music too

Here I go stirring up controversy again :eek: ...

Here is a nice thread on the PB1-ISD 320 watt $599 box sub

http://www.hometheaterforum.com/htforum/showthread.php?s=&threadid=190398

http://www.svsubwoofers.com/subs_pb1_isd.htm

The Rocket SW10 is nice also but not quite SVS territory but nice finish.

http://www.av123.com/products_product.php?section=speakers&product=34.1

If you are even remotely considering the SVS sub go to a site called http://www.audioenvy.com and demo one for yourself locally by someone who already bought one. It's free.
 
Rob Babcock

Rob Babcock

Moderator
No controversy, Dr. Anthony, just common courtesy. The tube models you listed were already rejected by the poster. As you've already identified yourself as a dealer, you must use caution to avoid appearing to be a shill.

You seem like a decent guy, so I don't mean to single you out, Doc A. Many sites have rules about the types of posts that dealers can make recommending their own products. The forum area here is relatively new, and this issue really hasn't come up before. If it becomes an issue, we'll address it at a later time. For now I'm just giving you a friendly heads-up.
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
Dr. Anthony SVS is a great company but the cylinder subs are not exactly what I had in mind. As far as the rocket sub I am sure it is no where near the performance of the SVS Tube, though I would have hoped you would have said more about it than nice finish.

I believe Rob to be right when he says be less shrill. You should try and come across as more of an expert and less of a salesman.
 
D

Dr. Anthony

Audioholic Intern
My apologies again

We just started being a "dealer" only this past month and just started advertising just a week ago. I am a pediatrician and do not know the proper "dealer" etiquette or the proper avenues to continue to express ourselves without being accused of "advertising". I usually just speak my mind in forums but now everything is viewed with skepticism and ulterior motives :( by many if I identify myself as a "dealer" although I continue to say the same things I have been saying for years. I believe in honesty and I guess I could easily have posted as "anonymous" but that is just not my style and I feel it would be dishonest.

We were just castigated by posting some excellent bargains for fellow forum readers in your "deals" section even though "multi million dollar" stores were mentioned with similar bargains simply because it was mailed to him. I just apologized for that when I read your post. And now here I just posted a link to a rival forum and was waiting for the "fallout" :eek: from such a post, thinking I was causing more controversy with unbiased 3rd party information. I don't want the community to think we are some slime company looking for some free advertising, rather than a small caring mom and pop company made for enthusiasts by enthusiasts that own and sell the very manufacturers' products that already advertise in your forums. Other forums encourage us to tell our deals and talk about our products as it only increases the sales of the manufacturers that sponsor the forum. We are a unique entity that sells what no other company can. We are the only other company trusted to represent those manufacturers as spokesmen and are basically extensions of their advertising campaigns. Most do not know or understand this fact and think we are attempting to increase our sales when we only increase the sales of the forum sponsors. Our margins are even more ridiculously lower that the manufacturers.

I have been an enthusiast for many years and have amassed a decent amount of knowledge of the subject and have my own personal preferences. We loved our home systems so much we chose to sell those very products. It is much easier to give advice on the things you own so we decided to choose the products we personally found to be the best in comparison to others. The only real way to tell for oneself is to truly own the product or see it extensively demo'ed in a store or at your home. With the internet, that is almost impossible without listening to peers that own the products. The folks at audioenvy do a great job at helping this happen. We are in no way associated to them nor do we pay or accept any money for such endorsements. As an impartial entity we think they are great letting the person decide for themselves.

The spirit of the forum is for others to express their opinions and exchange information. For a forum to censor content because an opinion comes from a "dealer" I think would be wrong, me being a "dealer" or not. We would never disrespect another product to elevate our own as that is beyond decency but we have no problems providing objective and subjective evidence to support our positions. This is how all dealers should behave but I can understand why others do not and why some must be barred, censored or deleted as they may not follow the spirit of the open forum and use it solely as an advertisement vehicle.

We just want everyone to know they can trust us to be kind, helpful, respectful and jovial toward all forum users. We want that fact to be expressed to the management. This post may not be an appropriate modality to express it, but perhaps if we want to advertise officially we also have to test the forum and its usefulness for our purposes should we consider this a place to advertise. So far advertising in forums has not gotten us very many sales but has increased our exposure. If it cannot increase our sales then it is not of much use to us as an advertisement vehicle. Even if we decide to not advertise that should not mean that we shouldn't be able to post or be normal productive members answering questions on things that we are experts and expressing our opinions.

Unregistered:

We tried not to say much for fear of sounding like a salesman but apparently that is unavoidable once people see us as a "dealer." Every word is “sales pitch “every opinion deemed” advertising apparently unless we endorse a product we do not sell. I could go on forever about the SW10 or SVS as a company or others, but we chose our products for a reason. If you read my post you will see that all I did was state actual facts and my personal experiences with SVS. I am sorry that I missed the fact that you stated you "did not like the beer keg" look, but once placed on its side behind a couch or under a couch table, it kinda disappears. With a tablecloth and a lamp it all together disappears :). Box subs like the Adire, Energy, SVS, HSU, Velodyne, etc all sound very similar but the question is what is its your main purpose, room size, decor, ultimate spl requests and degree of accuracy?

SVS has been know in the HT circles for years but it is a very good compliment to music as well, but that mainly is not its primary audience. The cylindrical subs though very efficient, only have one color...black sock... unless you buy the top of the line which is out of the question for you. They make others in square box subs with veneers, but they are out of your price range. HSU also is a very close contender than most of the other subs.

Outlaw makes a nice box as well, same amps and HSU engineering helps, 12" driver like most, flaired ports etc. Velodyne we have felt put too much into feedback control in their upper systems being very power hungry and unecessary mostly as demonstrated by many other subs. The best way to see what you like is to go with a company that you can get your money back with an audition should you not like it.

Go to a local store and hear the Velodyne, contact Audioenvy to hear an SVS and Adire. You might be able to find a HSU at your local high end store. At this level, I would say pick one that goes best with your decor. This is what we tell everyone as there is form and their is function and the two have to live in the same area, especially if there is a spouse involved.

No wife likes a humungous square box in the living room or a 4 foot tall black marshmallow that clashes with the rest of the furniture. The benefit of the rocket SW-10 is that it is is Cherry and it will match your systems. Right now cherry is the only one that is available as low gloss piano black and "Chocolate Rosewood" subs have not arrived. The SW-10 has a handsome cabinet with a cool grill, 200 watt amp 10" driver with a long excursion pulp woofer with a santoprene surround. I do not know the ultimate SPL output, but it is not exactly in the company of the other subs with 300+ watts. The UFW-10 is a little different story at $599, excellent cabinetry with end caps and multiple veneers, a sealed enclosure with 500 watts, a one band parametric eq which is very helpful, and an aluminum 10" long excursion driver. The sealed nature of the sub makes it extremely tight and we feel better suited more toward music and deep tones, not as efficient as a ported solution, but it can pull double duty quite easily.

You want the biggest bang for the buck yet want utility as well. The question is will 1-3 db less of ultimate output suffice to have a nicer cabinet? Remember also the bigger the wattage amp the more juice it sucks. I would go with more efficient models myself, especially on a budget when you know you want to squeeze every dollar and that other amp/dvd/tv etc system is pulling megawatts from the wall. That is why for a price point we like the new upcoming $400 PB10-ISD with a 300 watt bash amp as it will most likely dominate the segment over a HSU VTF-2 or anything else in that range by our expert opinion.

To throw a wrench into the works... have you ever considered using a bass shaking device over a real sub? Those units give the perception of bass, don't shake the house like a regular sub and can be isolated to furniture. This will keep their neighbors happy especially in the apartment setting but are no substitute for air pressure. They are great for movies and used by many many musicians all over the world.... Just another option for you. :)
 
D

Dr. Anthony

Audioholic Intern
For that kind of money

For that kind of money, he can go to Costco and buy a 10" KLH 100 watt sub for less than $100 and listen to the 50 Hz boom tone all day long. I do not think you understand what exactly he is looking for, no disrepect intended. We are talking about apples and oranges.

BTW the first link you posted is no longer available. We only see the MTX sub in the second.
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
Yes saving money would be most beneficial to me. However I do think Dr. Anthony is right, I am looking for something in a different league. Though I have heard several refferals to this sub I am still a bit skeptical. I am not as sold on this the parts express sub as I am on SVS and HSU.

I really like the Rocket Onix UFW-10 but it would cost to much ($635.00) delivered this would take my whole budget and leave nothing for a cable.
I am seriously considering a PSB 5i for its delivered price of $459 and its great reviews.

I am open to any suggestions. Will be heading to a local retailer tonight to hear the new Velo's
 
D

Dr. Anthony

Audioholic Intern
Just remember

You will not get HSU or SVS output at 25 Hz. Most main systems bottom out at 40 Hz. A very good main system drops to 30. Anything under 30 you start to feel more than hear. Moving a woofer down low requires a tremendous amount of energy and air and cone movement. SVS althought they do not tell you, each amp has been carefully tuned at the factory. That gives 2-3 db of headroom and extra grunt that no sub that stops at 30 will be able to supply. The HSU is very similar in that they too use BASH but in a lower wattage. The PSB is even less wattage than the STF-3 (at 150 watts).

From the PSB website "SOUND PRESSURE LEVEL Maximum @ 100Hz 109 dB" is nowhere near the 120+ DB you get with the SVS or the HSU at 40 Hz. Remember every 10 db is a doubling of sound output. You would need approximately 2 of those subs to equal 1 SVS or HSU.
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
You seem to be missing the point I have neignbors and am simply looking for something that is going to fill in the bass, not something that is going to deliver 108db at 25hz and get me evicted. How could you possible think I would compare the 5i against the Hsu or SVS?? If that were the case I would put a Paradigm PW-2200 up against either one but we are talking way more than $600.

SVS may reign in sound quality but the shape and size is quite obtrusive to anyone. Such so is the case for me that I wouldn't consider an SVS sub in my livingroom.

If you wanna talk power to the punch let's compare your Hsu & SVS subs to the much smaller REL's, not much of a contest there. The one foot square REL Q200e will out rumble the Hsu and SVS as will the M&K V-150 mkII

My point is there are a lot of subs that can bring it, Hsu and SVS are known for value for the bang, not the end all in subwoofers.
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top