Got to admit that takes some balls to post on that thread. Those guys seem to be talking on a different plane as to what projectors do and why they do it.
Like you, my experience is also only limited to what I have seen and what I have read and I have been commenting on what I have actually seen myself. I have seen many projectors, running on several kinds of screens in different types of light controlled rooms, with many of the home theater dealers, stores, and even home networking locations that have them in the Austin area.
I have not come accross a one that has either the Qualia or the Fujitsu, nor any 1080p projector for that matter, and from what I have seen demoed for me on many different combinations of projectors/screen/and ambient light, nothing I have seen comes anywhere close to my projector on my firehawk in my pitch black media room.
I probably should allow for the fact that most of those projectors probably werent tweaked and optimized to my preferences, (in contrast /brightness /etc) but all those things withstanding the Sharp XV-Z12000 setup that I have in my media room blew them all away.
My neighbor has a setup on a 120 inch dalite screen that gets left in the dust, too.
Now I have no doubt that a 1080p projector of any sort would provide superior picture with 1080i source material and probably even upconvert 480 material pretty nicely. Although, what I have read indicates that because of lack in "black levels" the Qualia and LCD 1080p, specifically the Fujitsu, several what I would call "people who know what they are talking about" seem to believe that a projector running the mustang 2+ chip from TI, even the Sharp specifically, gives them a run for their money because picture quality takes into account more than just picture resolution.
As you have probably seen, from reading that thread that I attached, those people posting there arent farting around with their knowledge of projectors. Those people either have spent money on projectors of that caliber, deal with them (as dealers), or both.
Now Im certain your opinion matters as much as any one of theirs, and Ill take you for your word on it. I have to see for myself that there is a significant picture quality increase from what I have versus the Qualia or the Fujitsu before I even think about dropping anywhere near $20kish on a projector.
I will check out your site in more detail, and will definitely give you a shout to talk shop with you. Maybe we can work out a deal on a RX-V4600.
I was contemplating the Denon 4806, but because I am in the want for the Denon 5910 and might be looking at a 1080p projector sooner than later .. i better take the easy way out on my receiver.
Looking forward to hearing your input and feedback on the projectors. Maybe I can give you some tweaks to do with your XV-Z12000 before you
remove it to make it look as good as it can. Specially if you tack it onto a firehawk screen.
Mike