which sub is better...

[dabears]

hey guys I'm undecided which sub to pull the trigger on.. the PA-150 or PL-200. Am gonna use it pretty much for everything ,movies,music,tv etc. I'm prolly going to pair them with promonitors 1000 for fronts ,procenter 1000 for c, promonitors 800 for rears. Incase you guys wanna know my budget on a sub is 300-350 .

Thanks!

 

[dabears]

anyone out there that would like to help me out?

 

[Steve81]

Between those two, I'd opt for the PA-150 based on the measurements of both by Josh Ricci. Still, I'd reconsider the allocation of funds. For most people, the subwoofer is the last thing you'd want to skimp on.

 

[fuzz092888]

I think any of these would be a better option, although waiting never hurt anyone, since there is significant improvement to be had if you are able to bump the budget up to $5-600.

M8 Powered Subwoofer

STF-2 Subwoofer

CSX12 Mark II - Cadence Sound Store

 

[GoFastr]

If you're talking about the BIC Acoustech PL-200, I got mine on sale from acousticsounddesign.com for $279 + free shipping. Regular price $329.

I measured it with my own ears and for the price it performs well on both music and movies for me until I can step it up with the big boys. I think they might call it the VK-12 now though.



Bic America VK-12 Powered Subwoofer



"We proudly introduce the BIC/Acoustech Platinum Series PL-200
subwoofer. If you are looking for a top-tier subwoofer at an affordable
price, we strongly suggest you audition the Acoustech PL-200. Although
both the H-100 and PL-200 are superb value performers, the PL-200 is
driven by an audiophile state-of-the-art BASH amplifier capable of
delivering up to 1000-watts dynamic peak output.
For extended bass response, the PL-200 also has more internal cabinet volume than the H-
100. The PL-200 can move an impressive volume of air with exquisite
control while delivering prodigious amounts of bass power for both music
and theater applications. A sleek cabinet with hand-rubbed black lacquer
top and bottom offers a deep gloss shine that is more scratch resistant
than many lacquer finishes on the market. Like the Acoustech H-100, we
guarantee the PL-200 will knock your socks off, especially for the price!"

Price (MSRP): $629 /Each
Design:
Front-Firing 12" Long-Throw Powered Subwoofer with state-of-the-art
BASH amplifier. *Additional Features: Adjustable Crossover, adjustable
volume control, automatic signal sensing, high level inputs, and both
Dolby Pro Logic & Dolby Digital/DTS inputs.
Specs:
Frequency Response: 22Hz - 200Hz, adjustable crossover & volume
controls.
Sensitivity: 110dB @ 30Hz Dynamic Range
Drivers: Heavy Duty 12" poly-injected woofer with high power magnet
and long excursion surround.
Magnetic Shielding: NO
Gold-Plated Terminals:YES
Recommended Power: Built-in State-of-the-Art BASH
Amplifier - 1000 Watts Dynamic Peak Output, 250 Watts RMS
Continuous.
Impedance: 8 ohms
Dimensions: 17 1/4"H x 14 3/4"W x 19 1/2"D
Weight: 52 lbs. Each
Warranty: Extended 8 Years Parts & Labor on Driver, 2 Years on Amp &
Associated Electronics.

 

[dabears]

im going more the PA-150 I read good reviews on both subs but some ppl say the PL-200 doesn't good when playing music?

 

[j_garcia]

I will second the Cadence CSX-12 MkII. Very good budget sub for the price.

Instead of the STF-2, I'd opt for the VTF-1 for a bit more money VTF-1 MK2 Subwoofer

 

[Steve81]

im going more the PA-150 I read good reviews on both subs but some ppl say the PL-200 doesn't good when playing music?

Honestly, I wouldn't expect either subwoofer to satisfy a discriminating listener for music. The question is: how discriminating are you?

 

[GoFastr]

im going more the PA-150 I read good reviews on both subs but some ppl say the PL-200 doesn't good when playing music?

Well, in your price range for the mere fact that the PA-150 has the larger 15" woofer I'd go with that for the extra $50.

But I listen to a lot of reggae music which is notorious for bass and I guarantee you I get my $329 worth from my PL-200!

Just can't wait to upgrade to an SVS or maybe FW later on.