Good Home theater as a gift....

ImcLoud

ImcLoud

Audioholic Ninja
We {me and my 2 brothers, splitting 3 ways $250 each} decided to build my sister a home theater for her House Warming gift {she just bought a nice raised ranch {foreclosure, she stole it}. So her House warming party is in 2 weeks, We decided to split the cost of getting her a decent home theater since she has been asking us what to buy... She likes towers, and her living room is around 200sqft with 7ft ceilings... Our budget is $250 each so $750 total, installed...

The party is going to be a surprise, she is getting picked up at the airport {has a wedding to go to in Utah} and coming home to a party {I cant think of anything worse, its going to suck for her, lol}.

Heres what Im thinking...
$200
Jamo S 426HCS 3 5.0-channel speaker system | Vanns.com

$120
DENON AVR-391 5.1 Channel AV Home Theater Receiver | Accessories4less

$360
STF-2 Subwoofer

Then that leaves a little less than $100 to make her speaker wires and get stands for the surrounds...

What do you think?
I heard the Jamo 426 towers {never heard the complete system} and they weren't dreadful, they were actually pretty laid back, and the bass was decent, it was only the 2 towers I heard no sub, and they sounded decent, definitely entry level... They were being powered by a 2 channel pyle receiver so they should be pretty easy to run..

The HSU sub will be perfect for her room, and I have heard them and own them so this is a keeper..

The AVR, I kind of just picked something that fit with the budget, Im not sure if her new tv is 3d or not... But this should work...

One of my brothers wanted to get her a HTIB with an Ipod dock fro $720 shipped, so I think this will be a step up
 
Adam

Adam

Audioholic Jedi
...so no way to get speakers behind there...
You're just not trying hard enough.

:p

That's very generous of you and your brothers. Congrats to your sis on her new home. 7-foot ceilings would make me feel like a giant. :D

One thing to consider if you haven't - you could put $750 towards part of a 5.1 system, and let her expand on it. If she was asking what to get, she must have been planning on spending something on it. That way, you could expand your options and step up a notch in performance. I'm not saying that your picks are bad (not at all) - I'm just throwing out an idea.
 
afterlife2

afterlife2

Audioholic Warlord
One thing to consider if you haven't - you could put $750 towards part of a 5.1 system, and let her expand on it..
Like the new Pioneer's towers and center.:D
 
ImcLoud

ImcLoud

Audioholic Ninja
You're just not trying hard enough.

:p

That's very generous of you and your brothers. Congrats to your sis on her new home. 7-foot ceilings would make me feel like a giant. :D

One thing to consider if you haven't - you could put $750 towards part of a 5.1 system, and let her expand on it. If she was asking what to get, she must have been planning on spending something on it. That way, you could expand your options and step up a notch in performance. I'm not saying that your picks are bad (not at all) - I'm just throwing out an idea.
Yah I am 6'5" and feel like godzilla in there, but its an older house the ceilings are actually around 7' 3" but I am so used to my house some of my ceilings are 24' and even my basement ceiling is around 10...

I was thinking about just buying her the sub and her front 3 speakers but then its not going to be a working system, and now she has to spend money to finish our gift.... Figured the only thing she would want to upgrade is the avr, that why spending $120 is good, since she can always sell it and put the money towards something better... I think the 5.1 its self it plenty good enough for her for at least 10 years, she is by no means a critical listener and wont be using it for music, just tv and movies...

She would honestly be happy with the performance of a $300 HTIB, so this should blow her away... I know I have to get her a sub that has auto on, because she would probably never put it on,
 
BoredSysAdmin

BoredSysAdmin

Audioholic Slumlord
I think it's pretty decent budget setup
I only have concerns re: AVR
the speakers rated at 6 ohm and might need a better amp section. Plus Audyssey MultEQ XT is much better than 2EQ
DENON AVR-1712 7.1 A/V Surround Receiver | Accessories4less

If Chase Home theater ever gets their 10" subs back in stock - these are probably one of the best bang for the buck (ballpark of $400)
 
Adam

Adam

Audioholic Jedi
Those new Pioneers are $500 delivered for four speakers and a center (towers, bookshelves, and center are all $100/each at TigerDirect right now with free shipping - I just checked).

Stands will probably run you about $50-$60 if you go with bookshelves, and speaker wire should be relatively cheap unless you need to go with flat cable or something fancy.

That will still let you get that receiver, or one similar in price. Just no sub, yet.
 
Adam

Adam

Audioholic Jedi
I finally got around the checking out the Cnet review, and they list the entire 5.1 Pioneer system as having an MSRP of $630 (two towers, two bookshelves, center, and sub). So, the TigerDirect sale prices don't seem awesome in that case. Doesn't mean they aren't still good, though.
 
ImcLoud

ImcLoud

Audioholic Ninja
Im really set on the vtf2 sub, I have heard a lot of subs and for $320 there is nothing close, although I havent heard the dayton yet, it looks good and I am a fan of the dayton 75x2 amps, they make good stuff...

As far as the avr, I dont think she is going to be pushing it to its limits anytime soon... And this is something she can upgrade in the future if she does want something more powerful.
 
S

shadyJ

Speaker of the House
Staff member
Imcloud, these types of items are basically pieces of furniture, since they are so large and visible. I think buying someone a home theater as a gift is a great idea, but I wouldn't want to spring it as a surprise on anyone, as you would basically be decorating their homes for them. If I wanted to give home audio or video items to someone as a gift, I would make absolutely sure they are a hundred percent cool with the item's appearance, and have them know what to expect in size.

With that being said, one approach you might take is just go 2.0 for now, and get some solid bookshelf speakers that look so nice she couldn't possibly object to them. One advantage to that approach is some sturdy good looking speakers could last a long time (barring abuse), and so it would be something that brings great returns. Some fancier speakers might also compel the recipient to take greater care for them than something which wouldn't seem to be as higher-end, in appearance at least- 'pride of ownership' and all that. Some suggestions I would make in that vein that is within your budget:
KEF Q300
Aperion Verus Grande
Swan D2.1se + stand
NHT Classic Two
You might also try one of these kits from parts express, there are some very lovely speakers in there, they will likely perform above their price point, they are easy to assemble, and the fact that you put them together may engender a greater affection for the gift from the recipient. Check this one out, it is heavy-duty and gorgeous. Take a look at this one too, very tasteful speaker that will also be a terrific performer. Watch the little videos embedded at the product pages to see how easy it is to assemble those speakers, you could have it done within a half hour, and all you need are basic tools, like a screw driver and hammer. I haven't put together one myself, but it really looks like a piece of cake.
 
ImcLoud

ImcLoud

Audioholic Ninja
Imcloud, these types of items are basically pieces of furniture, since they are so large and visible. I think buying someone a home theater as a gift is a great idea, but I wouldn't want to spring it as a surprise on anyone, as you would basically be decorating their homes for them. If I wanted to give home audio or video items to someone as a gift, I would make absolutely sure they are a hundred percent cool with the item's appearance, and have them know what to expect in size.

With that being said, one approach you might take is just go 2.0 for now, and get some solid bookshelf speakers that look so nice she couldn't possibly object to them. One advantage to that approach is some sturdy good looking speakers could last a long time (barring abuse), and so it would be something that brings great returns. Some fancier speakers might also compel the recipient to take greater care for them than something which wouldn't seem to be as higher-end, in appearance at least- 'pride of ownership' and all that. Some suggestions I would make in that vein that is within your budget:
KEF Q300
Aperion Verus Grande
Swan D2.1se + stand
NHT Classic Two
You might also try one of these kits from parts express, there are some very lovely speakers in there, they will likely perform above their price point, they are easy to assemble, and the fact that you put them together may engender a greater affection for the gift from the recipient. Check this one out, it is heavy-duty and gorgeous. Take a look at this one too, very tasteful speaker that will also be a terrific performer. Watch the little videos embedded at the product pages to see how easy it is to assemble those speakers, you could have it done within a half hour, and all you need are basic tools, like a screw driver and hammer. I haven't put together one myself, but it really looks like a piece of cake.
I already ordered everything, wanted to get it in before the weekend, she was asking me what to buy, Im pretty sure these will fit her taste, as when she seen my ascend 340s on the tower bases she wanted to get a set of them, and them are the ugliest speakers I own... I compared the wood to her furniture and it is actually a close match that was a total accident though...

She is a very simple person, me and my brothers have big home theater systems, and she has always been the "keep the tv I had when I lived with our parents cause it still works" type... When we hung her TV on the wall for her, she couldnt believe all it consisted of was running the wires through the wall and a steel bracket, she thought she would need to cut the wall and nail in supports and call an electrician, ect... It took me and my brother 2 hours {included eating lunch she made us}, we ran 2 25' HDMI cables and a 14-2 romex up through her wall form a nice clear spot next to her couch where her cable box is going to be. Installed a 2x4 handi box for the power and a cluster cover for where the hdmi's came out near the couch..

But anyway, I think she will be very happy with the system we picked her, and now when I go over there for holidays, I can relax with a decent theater to listen to...
 
I

Irishman

Audioholic
Are those out, yet?
Yup, I have them, myself. Or at least the center and tower fronts. I got mine at Best Buy because I like immediate gratification and I could take them home with me. The tweeter in the 2012 models is the true star, going high enough to make last years' models sound positively muddy by comparison. And even though it seemed counterintuitive to me, with smaller drivers than last year, Andrew Jones was able to eke out more bass extension (not enough that you won't need a sub, but surprising nonetheless.

Even if you paid list for the 5.1 set, you'd pay about $600, including an 8" powered subwoofer. However, with as good as the towers, center and surrounds are, the sub doesn't quite perform up to their level. It's smooth and great for music at moderate levels, but fails to deliver that kick in the chest feeling more competent subs can.

You could pick up something a Bic F12 for about $20 more than the Pioneer mark 2 sub, and still have money for cables and maybe even a basic blu-ray player for her.

Hope that helps
 
Last edited:
ImcLoud

ImcLoud

Audioholic Ninja
UPDATE:

Everything is all set up and of course she loves it...

This jamo set is really worth the $200, that is a really good price for everything you get, and they sound really good, the tweeters are the weakest link but by far better than any theater in a box setup you can find... The HSU stf2 sub was the last thing to arrive, but it sounds awesome, I dont care what anyone says that thing makes more, quality bass than any sub I have heard under $550, for $320 plus shipping it is a steal for sure... Line up 4 HTIB subs and they wont be half as good... That is the go to budget sub... It is actually too much for the room.... But I balanced everything out and set it all up, the jamos mids are definitely above their price range, and I played a little medium soud level music through them and they sound really good.. The boxes are well made, everything has good weight and a good finish.. For $200 they give you a lot in all categories, finish, sound, power handling, looks, and time will tell about reliability...
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top