A

arkight

Junior Audioholic
Which TV would you choose and why?

Panasonic GT30 65" or Sharp Aquos Quatro 70"

Or is ther somethe better out there i sould be looking at.

Maybe a samsung 60" led or Sharp Aquos LED Quatro 60"
 
BMXTRIX

BMXTRIX

Audioholic Warlord
The GT30 and the D7000/8000 series from Samsung are very comparible and should be considered strongly against each other. The VT series from Panasonic would be what I would call the 'best'.

I would rate the better Samsung LED/LCD displays as producing a better image than the Sharp display, and the better Sony displays are as well.

So, there is a fair bit that will deliver a better image than the Sharp 70", but the Sharp doesn't suck, and as a value based product it is an industry leader. You simply can't find a display that bright, that large, with solid quality and very good image for anywhere near the price they are selling it at from anyone else.

I'm pretty much convinced that I will end up with the Sharp 80" in my home in the next 1-2 years and I will move my 64" Samsung plasma to my basement setup.
 
darien87

darien87

Audioholic Spartan
I'd be seriously considering that Sharp 70" if it was 3D. I figure if I'm going to spend a few grand on a new TV I might as well get one with 3D. Don't know if I'll get into 3D or not but why not? I've already got a couple of 3D BD's.
 
F

FirstReflection

AV Rant Co-Host
Assuming that either 65" or 70" is ok by you just in terms of screen size, the question of whether to get a very good plasma or a good LCD comes down to your viewing environment, IMO.

In sheer measureable metrics - like black level, off-axis viewing, color uniformity and REAL contrast (not the made up "dynamic" contrast numbers that all manufacturers quote), the best plasmas still outperform LCDs. But there's one, key issue, which is that plasmas don't look their best when the room is lit!

In a dim or dark room, a top level plasma is the best choice.

But in anything more than "dim" lighting (as in just barely enough to read a newspaper level of light), plasmas start to wash out a little bit, and those lovely, inky blacks start to turn grey :(

Up until the 70" Sharp LCDs came out, there honestly wasn't a single LCD (LED backlit or otherwise) that I would have recommended! The reason? ALL current LCDs use a ridiculously glossy screen surface that makes them utterly unwatchable in anything other than pitch blackness! At least to me :p

But thank the heavens, Sharp smartened up and made some matte screen LCDs again! Hooray!!!

The LC-70LE7xxU series are the ONLY current LCD TVs that I recommend! And thankfully, they're really good! They use a full-array LED backlight for even illumination of the screen - none of the crappy "edge-lit" LED nonsense or the "cloudy" CCFL backlights. The backlighting is NOT local-dimming, but the 700 series Sharp models still produce nice, deep black levels. They are very bright. The color reproduction is good. And Sharp gives adequate user controls to dial in the color and greyscale performance rather well. For similar controls in a plasma, you need a Samsung or the VT30 series Panasonics. The GT30 series lacks everything but the most basic user picture controls.

So, very simple - if you have lighting that is any brighter than "dim", I'd recommend the LC-70LE734U if you don't care at all about 3D or the LC-70LE735U if you DO want 3D. Same television, just 3D vs. 2D-only :)
 
96cobra10101

96cobra10101

Senior Audioholic
Which TV would you choose and why?

Panasonic GT30 65" or Sharp Aquos Quatro 70"

Or is ther somethe better out there i sould be looking at.

Maybe a samsung 60" led or Sharp Aquos LED Quatro 60"
I just went through this. Samsung 7000 or 8000 or Panasonic GT or DT for quality. I would recommend plasma over LED for better off axis viewing.
 
A

allargon

Audioholic General
I just went through this. Samsung 7000 or 8000 or Panasonic GT or DT for quality. I would recommend plasma over LED for better off axis viewing.
I would recommend plasma or DLP over LED for accurate colors and less motion blur, too. The black levels should be better on most plasmas unless the LED has local dimming.
 
M

Midwesthonky

Audioholic General
I went with the Panasonic GT30. My brother would have gone with the LCD. He likes LCD and I like Plasma. It comes down to personal preference and factors such as the room you will watch it in.

I personally don't like how the LCD's look. It's my personal opinion and if I'm spending the money, I'm getting what I want.

Not really a good answer to your question, but you need to focus on what it is you want out of it. Have you compared the pictures? Does the difference in how fast motion looks on each bother you?:eek:
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top