Please help: +/- $300 budget speaker type, selection, layout, etc.

V

venessian

Audioholic Intern
PLEASE HELP: +/- $300 SPEAKER TYPE, SELECTION, LAYOUT, ETC.

Hello, I’m new to this forum and would really appreciate some basic advice on setting up a budget stereo system. It has been about 20 years since I have bought anything and I am feeling overwhelmed after researching here and on the AVS and AudioKarma forums and the internet in general. So much has changed since then….

I have read several relevant threads here but am still quite unclear. Sorry for another newb thread!

My wife is a part-time opera singer, so it is important that the set-up be geared for her to listen to her practices and other works, as well as a range of music from classical to jazz and blues. We have a nice television but have never looked into home theater, etc. That would only be a by-product, not a major criterion at all. We do have several Sonos pieces throughout the house. The only stereo components we use now (these are old and I don’t know if they are worth keeping…but if possible we would like to in order to contain costs) are a Philips FR 920 A/V Surround receiver; a Sony C77ES CD player; and a DVD player. The no-name speakers are trashed and that is our primary need.

If it helps, I have attached a plan of the living area, which is a bit complex perhaps. The space is quite long (37’) but is divided into 2 sections in terms of height. The shaded area that has red dots over (where the stereo/TV are) is about 12’ x 14’ with a flat ceiling about 8.5’ high, while the area not dotted rises from 8.5’ at the windows to about 16’ high at the curved dashed line. The floors are terrazzo except for 3 rugs; the walls are plaster over brick; the ceilings are drywall, so a lot of hard surfaces.

(Oops, can't post images until have 5 posts...will attach later.)



I realize that it is best to listen to speakers before buying, but I’m not even sure what to ask a salesman although I will go to some stores with the same questions listed here; I would just feel better with a bit more knowledge before running that gauntlet….

Despite my wife’s avocation, we are not really audiophiles, not tech geeks and are on a very tight budget. Basically, new speakers at $300-$400 are the first necessity, and this is where it gets confusing. I have read all the “best speakers under $300” etc. threads here and elsewhere, but I’m feeling information overload because I don’t know how to set my criteria.

Other than budget, I don’t know if I should look at bookshelf or floor (bookshelf would be better for space; the usual Cambridge S30; KEF Iq30; Axiom M3v3; Monitor BR-2; Wharfedale 9.2; Energy; BW 685; Ascend; HTD; HSU; PSB; Paradigm; NHT SuperOne (can’t afford the Absolutes or Classics (which look nice) new); etc. suspects );
at full-range or 2 speakers + subwoofer;
or at a 5.1 setup such as some NHT SuperZeros + subwoofer.
The more I read the more lost I feel!

We are definitely very open to increasing the quality of the speakers by buying used, and will be looking to do that.

Any advice as to what speaker type, as well as on components (mainly receiver if we need a new one), will be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.

I am cross-posting this on a couple of other forums also, so apologies to those who read the same thread twice.
 
Last edited:
V

venessian

Audioholic Intern
Sorry for the bumps. I'm trying to insert the plan.
 
P

PENG

Audioholic Slumlord
but I’m not even sure what to ask a salesman ….
Just ask for their bottom line price. Typically you cannot go with what they tell you anyway.

The more I read the more lost I feel!

We are definitely very open to increasing the quality of the speakers by buying used, and will be looking to do that.
To me I wouldn't bother with used if you can find the best deal out there for a pair of Infinity P362 or P363. I think I paid $299.99 or less about a year of two ago for mine. In the area you indicated you are going to put them you can do without a sub to start with. Those speakers will give you very decent bass in that small room. They sound very neutral to me but I find the violin sometimes sound a little grainy on them but that's if I compared them to speakers that I paid more than 10X for.


Any advice as to what speaker type, as well as on components (mainly receiver if we need a new one), will be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.
If on a tight budget, look at the lower mid range Onkyo models, but if reliability is a concern then look to Yamaha, Pioneer or Denon/Marantz (tend to cost more, for less).
 
V

venessian

Audioholic Intern
Thank you for the reply.

Yes, I don't really look forward to the "salesperson experience".

So you recommend towers/floor rather than bookshelf? The Infinity get a lot of positive reviews, and I am really looking at the P163 because so many people say as you do that they are quite "neutral"; and the price is good. But you would recommend the 2 P363 over the P163?

Do you think we should upgrade the receiver? (Ours works fine, but is almost 20 years old at this point.)

Just to be clear, the "room" where the stereo is located is only enclosed on 3 sides. It is completely open to the high-ceiling dining area, so ideally the setup would sound good in both situations: 1: frontal, music; and 2: off-axis, dining. This is why I was thinking that perhaps 4 or 5 smaller speakers such as NHT SuperZero might work well, at the 4 corners/front center of the sitting area, so as to then reflect out, but I don't know.

 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top