I played this all weekend and I have to say they delivered. I am almost done with it first run through; I decided not to finish it off and delay the end until I had time to really commit to it. It ISN'T a shooter. The pace is quicker than previous REs, but it still has the same feel as the other games. It still gives you that sense of intimidation and cautiously looking around corners because you
know something is going to happen. There are a few good surprise moments and some excellent levels. Not so much in the way of puzzles, but overall I give it good marks.
It is comparable to RE4 and is better in a number of ways, though still similar enough that you know it is RE. What I think they missed on a bit is the difficulty. I started on the Veteran difficulty and died immediately because you are no match for the first few areas with the default weapons, however on the normal difficulty, even the boss challenges aren't quite tough enough; meaning that I was able to beat most or all of them the first time. Some of the sub-bosses present a bigger challenge. The bosses
look cool for the most part though
RE4 was quite a bit more difficult the first time through IMO, and was just right in terms of challenging without making you have to do something over 100 times to beat it - it gave you a better sense of satisfaction once defeating some of thsoe bosses.
There is a wider variety of environments than RE4 and some very large areas. There are some Uncharted style chaces thrown in for good measure as well. A decent variety of weapons, all familiar, and relatively easy to acquire and upgrade. Once you have those upgrades, things get easier...for a bit and then your enemies tend to become harder and balance things out. The inventory is still an issue, though greatly improved. You can carry only 9 items per character, but weapons only take up one space, unlike previously. D-pad access to items placed in corresponding locations is great too.
Like I said, it isn't an shooter, so fans of FPSs might not like the control schemes or a few issues (like not being able to move while aiming/shooting, reloading, wtf? didn't they learn?), but fans of RE4 should be plenty happy with this one. I have been playing solo (solo but you have the AI character assisting you), but tonight I think we will actually try a misson or two co-op with my son.
One other thing: I had no problem buying this. One place had sold out on its preorders, but Frys had at least 10 copies left. I checked online and found all local stores listing it as in-stock on Friday.