To some extent I believe in that. But someone could argue that creativity is all that you need.
Today we are surrounded by so much technologies, so many tools, that sometimes we tend to get sidetracked by the joy/need of experimenting/learning all that stuff, instead of keeping focused on making the tune.
Many records were made just with tape recorders and I'm not refering to multitrack
. So, if they could make all those records, with just basic stuff, do we really need all those VSTs?
I started with 4 track trackers on the Atari ST (ex: TCB Tracker) and I was able to make music. The relative limits of what the tracker could do, were minimized by the fast implementation of the music ideas. I didn't get sidetracked by adjusting reverbs, delays and other effects. I just poured the notes in. That really helped me focus on the music (creativity), instead of trying to get a good frequency and panning balance (rationality).
This year I going through a stage where I almost stopped registering my basic music ideas in the software. When I get a tune in my head, I get my mp3 recorder and sing to it (it's ugly, believe me). This way I can get the basic idea recorded and later on I can implement it on software, without worrying of loosing it.
I'm not radical to the point of negating the benefits of investing our time in learning our tools inside out and aquiring new skills (I've been reading a lot), but I think there's a fine balance between creativity and rationality. For me, it's helpful to separate both and alocate exclusive time to each. If I'm implementing an idea in my computer I always have to resist the rational tasks that will, without a doubt, make me loose the creative spark.
It helps a lot to reserve time to create some production templates that will help you quickly transfer your ideas. For my house template I created 2 mixers (one instruments/vocals and other for rhythm), some loop players, a drum computer and some percussion instruments, one or two basslines, pads, sine waves, orchestral strings, a grand pianno and an organ. I've got reverbs and delays on sends, a compressor on the drums and a mastering unit (compressor, eq, stereo maximiser) on the end of my audio chain.
But there's much more that I could do, I could organize my sample collection or better yet, throw it all away and learn to quickly implement any sound I make in my head. Unfortunately I've not yet mastered the art of audio synthesis. So much to learn, so little free time