There could be any number of issues here, not the least of which is the 75ft run. A 3.5mm jack (a headphone jack) will generally be an output with a low voltage. An RCA input expects a voltage that is a few volts, so combine a lower voltage signal and a long cable run, and you are not going to get great results. If the cable run is also parallel to any power wires, whether shielded or not, it could pick up noise. As mentioned, the noise in that line is going to be amplified by both amps. Since the Y is connected to both sides, you are likely getting feedback from one amp to the other, as you should NOT connect two amplifiers together from one source this way - at the very least a switch box of some type would be better.
Do you have noise if you disconnect one or the other of the connections? If so, is it only the longer run?