You could be experiencing cancellation of the waves, try adjusting the phase on one of the subs and see if it makes a difference.
Thanks for your quick reply though in this case I'm not sure this is what's happening and I'll explain why. Last night while recalibrating the spkr set up due to some room rearranging I could get a sound reading from only the left sub, nothing from right side sub. I turned off left side sub and right side sub was still unresponsive. It was late and I did pull the shelf unit away from the wall to mess with wiring but past experience has shown me that if only one sub is connected to the reciever's sub ouptput with or w/o Y splitter either will work. Hook up both via the splitter and only one will work.
The set up is this:
1. Pioneer VSX-515 w/ one RCA sub output
2. Two Yamaha YST-W015 subs with L/R inputs, L is also denoted as mono input
3. X over is set to 80 in reciever
4. using a 'found it in the junk drawer' Y spiltter to connect to sub's L(mono) input. Note that with splitter in place I can disconnect either sub and the other will work
5. volume on both subs is set to 12:00 position. Range is from 7:00 - 5:00
6. Sub phase set to in phase.
7. Sub output in reciever is set +9.5 in order to achive 75db reading on SPL meter at seating position when main volume is set at -25db.
8. One sub is connected via 15' cable the other via 25' cable.
I'm thinking of replacing splitter with better one with gold plated connectors and sub cabling with shorter lenghts now that both subs are up front 6'-8' should do it. But I'm just shooting in the dark with no real idea why this set up is not working as it seems to for many posters on this forum.
Any additional input/feedback would be appreciated.