I grok your misery, Dave. I dumped cable a couple of years ago and eagerly enjoy my Dish Network service. BUT...you may have the same issues with watching SD programming on your HD set even with sat service. Perhaps I don't understand the HDMI issues or the intricate nature of upscaling...perhaps the technology has changed...but when I tried HD with DishNet, the compression (or upscaling) artifacts ruined the SD programming so as to make it unwatchable. I had to change the resolution of the set for every switch between SD and HD programming in order to be a happy viewer.