Sometimes I think that I'd like to have my old Nikko rack mount separates with my old Bryston amp, Onkyo cassette deck and turntable. When CD's came out, I made the switch right away and it was a huge improvement over any other source. Now that we have digital interconnects and all the other built in improvements, I have no desire to go back to what I had in the 80's, even though I think what I had was very decent equipment (except the Bryston, I'd want that back).
If you want vintage sound, just record everything onto cassette, turn your speakers around to face the wall during playback and enjoy the hiss and muffle. Really, we're living in a golden age right now. Enjoy it.