No, that's not the return policy on defective product.
Here's the policy.
All I saw was an ad for a refurb of this particular speaker, but they do sometimes also carry new product (have had that experience myself where I ended up buying new after returning a defective refurb). The refurbs in my case were from Denon, and assume the refurbs in this case were from Definitive Tech's (a sister brand of Denon, tho so maybe same contractor handles the refurbs before A4L)
Mark Sabbarese (sp?) is the owner of A4L. Maybe the employee is the problem here, hard to know. I think it would be odd that they would ship you new product if you purchased refurb product, as their pricing wouldn't be the same.
ps the odds that both speakers, either refurb or new, would be simultaneously defective would be pretty high....