Don’t bring up HDCP!
Yes, this whole HDMI/HDCP issue has been very badly managed, with multiple issues creating misunderstanding over the years. In addition revisions have often been fraught with bugs.
The issue we have been discussing is just one of the most recent examples.
The fact is that with 4K and 8K, 12 ft. of an unpowered cable is the extent of the reliable limit. Even for a lot of domestic installations, that is not far enough. In that case, a powered active cable of some type is obviously required.
So, the useless response has been to refuse to certify cables that draw more current, than the HDMI spec. That is just not good enough and a disgrace. The current spec. is 55 ma. That is miniscule. Now I know that that 5 Volt output was originally designed as solely a control voltage. However it should have been updated to a powering supply voltage right at the time active cables became mandatory for many installations.
So, one potential solution would be to make the inclusion of a voltage inserter mandatory to certify an active powered cable.
The other solution would be make 500 ma say, part of the HDMI out spec. Manufacturers might object, as that would increase power demands from a complex and expensive board. However that could be done, and I'm sure would add cost.
Probably a better solution is to mandate a separate 5V powering port below every HDMI out port.
The reason that the voltage inserter is not ideal, is it increases the effective depth of the unit. In my case everything is in a 19" rack I can walk behind. However to allow for a reasonable curve, an extra 3.5" is required behind a receiver or pre/pro to accommodate a voltage inserter.
This is an issue that needs addressing and sorting out fast. I have fielded a lot of questions on this, and what to do when a longer HDMI run is required, is not clear to most. It was not clear to me, and I had to figure all this out.
I have fielded one post from a member where using an optical cable without a voltage inserter blew his HDMI board. Strictly speaking that is not covered under warranty, as more current was pulled from the HDMI port than spec.
We need pressure applied all round on this, as it will be a source of greater and greater frustration, if it is not sorted out.