What if I say I loved Watchmen, hated 300 Rise of an Empire, and I thoroughly enjoyed Star Wars VII but hated BvS?
I say, "Too many variables".
I think too many things factor into how we enjoy any given movie - our current moods, the latest movies we saw, how friends and family feel about the movies, our personal pet peeves, etc.
Sometimes we can overlook certain aspects of the movies that would bother the heck out of other people.
I know there are shortcomings of "Man of Steel", "Batman V Superman", "300 Rise of an Empire", and "Watchmen". There are shortcomings of most movies.
But I was able to easily overlook those shortcomings and ENJOY those movies.
OTOH, Star Wars 7 bothered the heck out of me every 5 minutes.