Yes, it does make sense. When you use the auto mode it will default to the highest qualty possible decoding for the signal type it's being fed, which would probably be DD for a digital input. Also, keep in mindt hat DD doesn'tautomatically mean "sound in all channels all the time".
If you want the lower quality DPL which will force stuff from all speakers, then you have to select it. Odds are it goes to DPL when you feed it an analog signal, right? Analog doesn't support DD.
Since you say this only happened after your move, recheck your setup. you may have changed some setting during the move.
also, your wording is a bit difficult to follow so I was just guessing as to what you meant.