Alex, you are not crazy. Depending on your room, speakers, etc a system calibrated toplay equal @ 75 can be a few dbs off at a lower setting. How far off were they from the reference levels? When I had a JVC receiver I would get 2-3 dbs difference in some of the speakers from my reference of 85 to listening at around 70.
Now with my current setup, I calibrate at 85 then lower and double check the settings at my listening volume of 70. With my Yamaha receiver and new room, the levels are usually spot on.