Every site uses different reviewers; so different verdicts from different tastes and different equipment, different displays and different setups.
In the end, the best site is my own home. And the best reviewer is myself, on my own equipment and display, with my own tastes and critics.
And I'm good at it too. It helps that I sudied Cinema History and Photography at school. And I used to be a projectionist too. And I made my own film too.
You take a little bit from each reviewer to give you an idea from the transfer and extras, but you have to be very objective on your readings.
Many reviewers know nothing about cinematography and camera work. Same for properly and realistic audio sountracks.
There is more to Film than just a score number and special effects with CGI, and extra features where you learn something intelligent and valuable.
Most of the diferent reviews on most sites don't look at it as a Cinema Art form, but at a new technology with gimmick special effects and all that is superficial.
And the messages of films are very personal according to our own sensibilities, dispositions and comfort zones.
My own personal taste about "Coloring" is Natural colors and lights, but not everyone like a realistic looking picture. The majority of movies nowadays are altered in their colors, lights, contrast, CGI, volume levels unrealistic, effects that don't match the picture, etc., etc., etc.
I do read many reviews, but to be very honest here, I'll say that I trust more my own judgement.
Regards,
Bob
