It's still a "no-go" for me.
They might have a pretty good thing going with this partnership with Tivo, but I'm still not going to pay $2 to $5 to rent a movie (especially given the quality of the stream!) when I already pay a monthly fee of more than $20 to get 3 movies mailed to my house at a time, of which I can exchange for 3 more free movies in the store! I don't mind going to the store that much--it is right around the corner from my house! If they offered these movies for free (like Netflix) as long as you're a member, I might be tempted. Until then, you can forget it. I'm not excited. The only reason I haven't switched to Netflix is the quality of the movies. It's as bad as trying to watch a youtube video on a 52in screen.