Let our rigorous testing and reviews be your guidelines to A/V equipment – not marketing slogans
Administrator
admin should be listened to
Oppo BDP-103 & BDP-105 Blu-ray Q&A Interview
Anytime Oppo releases a new product it creates quite a buzz on the internet almost akin to Apple or Samsung releasing a new smartphone product. One difference however is that when Oppo releases new products, the changes are typically quite substantial rather than incremental. The BDP-93/95 Blu-ray players were prime examples of this and their newest BDP-103 and BDP-105 players seem to be following in their distinguished predecessors footsteps. We sat down with Jason Liao of Oppo Digital to explore these new players and dig deeper into what makes them a truly next generation Blu-ray platform. If you've got a question about these new players, this article likely will address them. If not, submit the questions in our support forum thread for this article and it will surely be answered by someone at Oppo.
Discuss "Oppo BLu-ray Q&A" here. Read the article.
Audiophyte
jandrewyang is a forum member in good standing
Incremental vs substantial
Like many I keep a close on what Oppo does, and they've been the recipient of well deserved accolade over the years. It just seems a stretch to say that this represents a substantial improvement in the product as compared to the smartphone industry. Within it's own market segment, it is without a doubt a substantial improvement but to compare against a product segment that is increasing performance metrics annually by factors of 2x is a bit fallacious.
Seriously, I have no life.
j_garcia should be listened to
Interesting; I didn't catch that before that they can also both be used as an external video upscaler as well. I am going to have to think a little harder on this one now, as I am leaning toward the 105 instead. Looks like the holidays are going to be expensive...
HT: Emotiva UMC-200, Emotiva XPA-3, 3X GR Research A/V-2s, GR A/V-1s, Epik Empire, Oppo BDP-83SE, URC R-50, APC-H10, Panamax 5100, PS3 Slim120G(500G) Bluejeans Cable
System Two: Marantz SR-8300, GR Research A/V-2s, Sony SCD-222ES SACD, Panasonic BD-65, PS3 60G (250G), My HT
Are you sure which side of the glass you are on?
Supreme Audioholics Overlord
gene should be listened to
I don't know, nothing in the iPhone 5 has me clamoring to upgrade my iPhone 4 nor am I really seeing a huge benefit going from an iPad2 to iPad3. It depends on what the user is looking for. These new Oppo's appear to offer a much faster user interface for streaming, better quality for streaming, 2k & 4k up conversion, upgrade performance for analog audio (SACD lovers rejoice) and more HDMI functionality, ability to use the player as a high end DAC and/or video up converter. The only downside is lack of analog video but that's happening with ALL blu-ray players after 2013 b/c of AACS mandate.Originally Posted by jandrewyang
Last edited by gene; 09-26-2012 at 02:56 PM.
Audiophyte
ebunton is a forum member in good standing
Good interview.
What high resolution PCM does the player convert SACDs to?
Does "high resolution" mean 88.2 kHz at 24 bits like the previous player or 176.4 or more?
Audioholic Spartan
PENG should be listened to
So it looks like the 105 will gain me more features but most likely not sound quality (not surprised). There will be a theoretical gain in PQ as well except my Elite Pro-111 can't take advantage of the 4K upscaling anyway. I will find out if the dealer would do a fair trade-in, and go from there.
Supreme Audioholics Overlord
gene should be listened to
No fan, redesigned VI filters, I think you can expect higher sound quality compared to the BDP95 and the new BDP103 via analog outputs despite the actual D/A converters are the same for the 95/105.So it looks like the 105 will gain me more features but most likely not sound quality (not surprised). There will be a theoretical gain in PQ as well except my Elite Pro-111 can't take advantage of the 4K upscaling anyway. I will find out if the dealer would do a fair trade-in, and go from there.
PENG (09-27-2012)
Audiophyte
jandrewyang is a forum member in good standing
Uncharacteristic
Can I preface this by writing, I am a long time reader and big fan of your work, so this is written with much respect.
It seems highly uncharacteristic, given the highly objective analysis you have provided on the site over the years, to read a statement which effectively distills the argument for qualification of relative advancement down to subjectivity. Arguing the perceived benefits of generational releases of the iPhone or iPad, in this instance, versus objective improvements seem at odds with your typical level of analysis. Especially when one considers that in the core subject matter of this site, that is precisely the type of thing you rail against.
Despite all the relative advances of the new Oppo models, in absolute terms they would most certainly have to be qualified as incremental. 4K upconversion of 2K material might be the lone feature that could objectively be considered substantial. Even then it would be arguable given the inherent resolution of the source material hasn't changed.
It's a nit that I picked. I acknowledge (and hopefully you can agree), as a former reviewer from another site, that the entire industry is largely filled with incremental improvements at the margins, with exceeding focus placed on products that, for the majority of the public, have well passed the point of diminishing returns.
Supreme Audioholics Overlord
gene should be listened to
Wow I didn't think injecting a little smartphone analogy would cause so much controversy. It's a good thing I didn't target just Apple as I'm sure the Apple fan boys would be boycotting this site right now
Of course I reserve final judgment until I can bench test one of these new players and the old 93/95 players are pretty darn good as you've seen in our reports.
I am looking forward to some of the feature/performance upgrades however:
- simultaneous HDMI with high res audio is a big plus for me
- better analog performance is always a good thing (even if subtle) especially for SACD
- better and quicker user interface of streaming services is a must - Netflix and youtube are almost unusable on the current Oppo players b/c the interface is too sluggish
- 1080p multi channel audio for Netflix is more than an incremental upgrade for heavy Netflix users
but thank you for your feedback. I'm actually glad people are finally posting on this thread as I figured this detailed interview filled with new product details would draw more response.
jandrewyang (09-27-2012)
Seriously, I have no life.
j_garcia should be listened to
I think it is because of what you said...the article does answer quite a few questions alreadyI'm actually glad people are finally posting on this thread as I figured this detailed interview filled with new product details would draw more response.
Peng mentioned there may be a difference video wise? I'm not sure I saw something that would indicate that, so are they different video wise?
HT: Emotiva UMC-200, Emotiva XPA-3, 3X GR Research A/V-2s, GR A/V-1s, Epik Empire, Oppo BDP-83SE, URC R-50, APC-H10, Panamax 5100, PS3 Slim120G(500G) Bluejeans Cable
System Two: Marantz SR-8300, GR Research A/V-2s, Sony SCD-222ES SACD, Panasonic BD-65, PS3 60G (250G), My HT
Are you sure which side of the glass you are on?
Posting Permissions
 |
LinkBack URL
About LinkBacks
Reply With Quote