Page 2 of 5 FirstFirst 1234 ... LastLast
Results 11 to 20 of 50

Thread: Would I benefit from a new cd player....

  1. #11
    Irvrobinson is online now Audioholic Field Marshall Irvrobinson should be listened to
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Posts
    1,583
    Thanks Given
    309
    Thanks Received
    754

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by flyboylr45 View Post
    Lol lol. Very true. I may not "hear" a difference but I'll definitely "see" the difference in both esthetics and wallet!!!!! ;-). We'll see. How would I set up a dbt at home? I guess have two identical CDs and play them at the same time connected to different inputs and have my wife switch them from the remote? The problem I see if they would not be level matched and the louder one would most likely be perceived as the better one. Any suggestions?
    No suggestions. Even a tiny difference in levels can lead you to a false impression of superiority. You know what the Adcom sounds like. I'd spend an evening listening to the new source and go by instinct. If it sounds better you'll know it after a couple of hours. If not, make your decision on esthetics, which I'm not at all discounting the value of. That Emotiva player I mentioned that I use as a transport *is* clunky, and there are times I'm thinking I'd just rather have something that looks and feels better.

  2. #12
    mtrycrafts's Avatar
    mtrycrafts is online now Audioholic Overlord mtrycrafts should be listened to
    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Posts
    14,777
    Thanks Given
    142
    Thanks Received
    1,092

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by flyboylr45 View Post
    Lol lol. Very true. I may not "hear" a difference but I'll definitely "see" the difference in both esthetics and wallet!!!!! ;-). We'll see. How would I set up a dbt at home? I guess have two identical CDs and play them at the same time connected to different inputs and have my wife switch them from the remote? The problem I see if they would not be level matched and the louder one would most likely be perceived as the better one. Any suggestions?
    Not an easy job unless you have the know how. Different inputs and outputs may have different volume levels that will manifest itself as one being better, not one being louder.
    At the minimum, you would need an accurate volt meter, a test tone CD to measure single tone's voltage at the speaker terminal for each input and output which needs to be withing 1%; if not, the capacity to level them. SPL meter is not good enough.
    So, off the bat, it is not easy. But, give it a try what you are able to do, have the wife randomly switch, or not, record which you think it is and at the end, compare your answers with hers; she also needs to record or have a random list prepared ahead of time for her switching.
    9 of 10, 12 of 15 guesses will show something.

  3. #13
    Irvrobinson is online now Audioholic Field Marshall Irvrobinson should be listened to
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Posts
    1,583
    Thanks Given
    309
    Thanks Received
    754

    Default

    It just occurred to me how high-end your system is. I get the feeling you think the Adcom is out of place in it, from a build quality and ergo point of view. If that's part of the issue, I agree. As I mentioned I'm getting increasingly annoyed with my ERC-2 over the same issue. It's just difficult for me to invest a lot of money in digital sources when I know the world will be different in a few years and I'll want something else.

  4. #14
    flyboylr45 is offline Audioholic flyboylr45 is gaining some recognition
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    orlando, fl
    Posts
    134
    Thanks Given
    2
    Thanks Received
    18

    Default

    That is part of it. I'm definitely not going to spend $6,000 if there is no difference in sound quality, but I'm curious if there would be a noticeable change. I definitely noticed it from a cheap old Techniques turntable to my current Clearaudio Concept. I think the difference in the cd player will be less noticeable but I'm still very curious. These are my toys and my main hobby and I spend hours on my off days just listening to music. I definitely know the aesthetics difference is huge but I won't base a purchase this size on aesthetics only.
    Home Theater:

    Marantz DV7005 processor
    Rotel RMB 1075 5-channel amplifier
    Monitor Audio S6 (fronts), S2 (center), SFX (rears)
    SVS PB-13 ULTRA
    Yamaha kxw-952
    Monster power line conditioner
    Marantz DV 7001 DVD Player
    LG 60" 3D tv
    Second Zone: Lepai

    Office:

    Emotiva mini-x100
    Adcom GCD-750
    Emptek E41-B

    Music Room:

    Mcintosh MA7000
    Focal 1028be!!!!!!!
    Esoteric SA-50
    Clearaudio Concept TT
    APC H15
    Wadia i171 iPod transport
    GIK Acoustic panels

  5. #15
    compcond is offline Audiophyte compcond is a forum member in good standing
    Join Date
    Feb 2012
    Posts
    1
    Thanks Given
    0
    Thanks Received
    0

    Default

    I purchased a DAC 1 HDR about 2 months ago to replace a Conrad-Johnson d/a-2b DAC, a DR-1 transport, and an SC-26 preamp and I strongly suspect the answer to your question is "yes."

    That being said you would be looking at the DAC 1 USB, not the HDR since you already have a preamp (the benefit of the HDR is that it eliminates the preamp and an interconnect). I would purchase it direct from Benchmark so you can return it if you feel it isn't an improvement.

    Finally, do yourself a favor a pick up a Logitech Squeezebox Touch and a 64GB USB thumb drive for under 3 bills. It will look completely stupid in your system but I did it and am completely unable to hear any difference between a CD played on the C-J transport and off the Squeezebox via coax digital to the HDR. CDs were ripped to Flac using Exact Audio Copy. I am, however, able to hear the difference between an original CD and a CD copy.

    And it's really nice to not have to handle CDs.

    Finally, once you've done all that you should pay a visit to hdtracks.com. 24/96 beats the living Bose out of RedBook CD.

  6. #16
    mtrycrafts's Avatar
    mtrycrafts is online now Audioholic Overlord mtrycrafts should be listened to
    Join Date
    Aug 2004
    Posts
    14,777
    Thanks Given
    142
    Thanks Received
    1,092

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by flyboylr45 View Post
    ... I'm definitely not going to spend $6,000 if there is no difference in sound quality, but I'm curious if there would be a noticeable change. I definitely noticed it from a cheap old Techniques turntable to my current Clearaudio Concept.....
    Are those both turntables? No wonder there are differences. As to audible sound differences of your question, You'd be very hard pressed to tell in properly controlled testing and certainly not $6k worth in my estimation.

  7. #17
    TLS Guy's Avatar
    TLS Guy is offline Audioholic Warlord TLS Guy should be listened to
    Join Date
    Oct 2007
    Location
    Benedict MN
    Posts
    9,876
    Thanks Given
    865
    Thanks Received
    4,017

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by flyboylr45 View Post
    That is part of it. I'm definitely not going to spend $6,000 if there is no difference in sound quality, but I'm curious if there would be a noticeable change. I definitely noticed it from a cheap old Techniques turntable to my current Clearaudio Concept. I think the difference in the cd player will be less noticeable but I'm still very curious. These are my toys and my main hobby and I spend hours on my off days just listening to music. I definitely know the aesthetics difference is huge but I won't base a purchase this size on aesthetics only.
    You have to understand that digital audio is in no way comparable to analog.

    Bits are bits, and the difference you will here between players is almost entirely dependent on the analog circuits. If you take a good player from 1984 and one made today, I bet you won't tell the difference.

    Turntables are totally different and totally dependent on precision engineering and manufacture. So your Technics and the Clearaudio are light years apart.

    However I could easily demonstrate to you some fine vintage turntables that would best your Clearaudio turntable. It is all down to precision engineering. Not so with digital audio. However longevity and reliability are different issues.
    Marantz DV 9600 Oppo BD-83 Marantz AV 8003 Quad current dumping amps X 7 Direct TV HD 20 HD DVR Carter audio workstation RME Fireface 800 Fujitsu 50XHA40 Front left and right Carter dual transmission line studio monitors MK II. Center Carter coaxial transmission line center speaker Rear Carter NFM-1s Center backs Carter dual transmission line studio monitors MK I. My system: - http://mdcarter.smugmug.com/gallery/...27077317_Pufg7

  8. #18
    PENG is offline Audioholic Spartan PENG should be listened to
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Ontario
    Posts
    5,327
    Thanks Given
    1,217
    Thanks Received
    1,444

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by flyboylr45 View Post
    That is part of it. I'm definitely not going to spend $6,000 if there is no difference in sound quality, but I'm curious if there would be a noticeable change. I definitely noticed it from a cheap old Techniques turntable to my current Clearaudio Concept. I think the difference in the cd player will be less noticeable but I'm still very curious. These are my toys and my main hobby and I spend hours on my off days just listening to music. I definitely know the aesthetics difference is huge but I won't base a purchase this size on aesthetics only.
    Just an aside, did you really believe that much in synergy, that you needed that Mc amp to tame that Be tweeter? I hope that wasn't the reason because I think I found a cheaper/better way to do it.

  9. #19
    Irvrobinson is online now Audioholic Field Marshall Irvrobinson should be listened to
    Join Date
    Dec 2004
    Posts
    1,583
    Thanks Given
    309
    Thanks Received
    754

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by TLS Guy View Post
    Bits are bits, and the difference you will here between players is almost entirely dependent on the analog circuits. If you take a good player from 1984 and one made today, I bet you won't tell the difference.
    Not to my ears. Not even close. BTW, isn't that Revox you've posted about a 225, which is a 14bit machine? Or am I wrong?

  10. #20
    flyboylr45 is offline Audioholic flyboylr45 is gaining some recognition
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    orlando, fl
    Posts
    134
    Thanks Given
    2
    Thanks Received
    18

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by PENG View Post
    Just an aside, did you really believe that much in synergy, that you needed that Mc amp to tame that Be tweeter? I hope that wasn't the reason because I think I found a cheaper/better way to do it.
    To tame the BE tweeter?? Is it because you think it is "bright"? I ran those speakers with a small Emotiva x-100 integrated, my rotel processor and amplifier and then the mac and never thought they were bright. I don't know if it's because the room is treated, but I never have gotten the impression that they were bright. I tell you what though, in my untreated family room, my Monito Audio S6 and the rotel processor / amp combo sounded bright to me.

    I bought the amp for many reasons. I like the way it sounds, looks, feels and brand name.

    TLSguy,

    I understand about digital and analog. So in essence, on any given cd player or digital source, what you're really hearing is the difference in DACs and their implementation. Correct? That is what brought me initially to this question. In a 16 year period of time, will the advances in DAC technology be audibly noticeable in a revealing system? I'm actually going to try and see if i can tell a difference between my Marantz DV7001 and the Adcom gcd-750. Once I get the new player to demo it at home, I'll leave all 3 connected and try to hear a difference. Who knows.... Either way it'll be a fun experiment for me.
    Last edited by flyboylr45; 02-23-2012 at 11:44 AM.
    Home Theater:

    Marantz DV7005 processor
    Rotel RMB 1075 5-channel amplifier
    Monitor Audio S6 (fronts), S2 (center), SFX (rears)
    SVS PB-13 ULTRA
    Yamaha kxw-952
    Monster power line conditioner
    Marantz DV 7001 DVD Player
    LG 60" 3D tv
    Second Zone: Lepai

    Office:

    Emotiva mini-x100
    Adcom GCD-750
    Emptek E41-B

    Music Room:

    Mcintosh MA7000
    Focal 1028be!!!!!!!
    Esoteric SA-50
    Clearaudio Concept TT
    APC H15
    Wadia i171 iPod transport
    GIK Acoustic panels

  11. The Following User Says Thank You to flyboylr45 For This Useful Post:

    PENG (02-23-2012)

Page 2 of 5 FirstFirst 1234 ... LastLast

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •