Which of the following phones should I choose on the basis of audio quality?

R

Rasindu

Audiophyte
Hello,
I recently broke my iPhone 6 and am looking to buy a new phone. Audio quality is a major factor for me to consider, namely the headphone experience. I am completely happy with the iPhone 6 experience therefore I'm looking for atleast the same quality on my new phone, or preferably a better experience.

My main choices are the S8, one plus 5 and iPhone 8. (I'm aware of far better quality phones for music such as the htc u11 and LG V20, but considering all factors, the above 3 are what I've come down to. Although, I'm very much interested in the pixel 2 XL, but pixels aren't known for their audio quality.)

Therefore I would like an opinion on the above 3 choices, ranked if possible from worst to best in terms of audio quality. As long as it is on par with the iPhone 6 quality I'm alright with that.

My main headphones are Sennheiser HD 558, and I use Sony in-ears while I travel. Preference is in clear and crisp, well balanced audio over bass heavy. I mainly listen to EDM, ROCK AND INSTRUMENTAL music.

Thanks in advance. Sorry if I have accidentally posted in the wrong forum, as this is my first post.
 
tyhjaarpa

tyhjaarpa

Audioholic Field Marshall
I have been using S7 for quite a while and I have been happy with the sound quality. I would assume the S8 should have good sound quality as well. I haven't compared to iphones tho so cant say anything about them.
 
R

Rasindu

Audiophyte
I have been using S7 for quite a while and I have been happy with the sound quality. I would assume the S8 should have good sound quality as well. I haven't compared to iphones tho so cant say anything about them.
Thank you for your reply :) That's great to know. I know for a fact that Samsung focused more on audio this time around . But I do need a comparison to an iPhone.
 
M

MrBoat

Audioholic Ninja
Thank you for your reply :) That's great to know. I know for a fact that Samsung focused more on audio this time around . But I do need a comparison to an iPhone.
I read a lot of reviews concerning this question recently and in the end, the opinions were so widely varied that I could not trust what I read.

I resided to the fact that I was going to have to try it before I buy it. Further yet, I'm still on the fence with the phones in general, and would likely end up with a dedicated play back/storage device like the Fiio instead.
 
Johnny2Bad

Johnny2Bad

Audioholic Chief
Basically all current high-value phones offer good sonic performance. The DACs in particular are reasonable quality, if not the very best.

If you use the amplifier, you may have trouble with In-Ear-Monitors, especially multi-transducer versions, but conventional phones and earbuds generally work fine. Considering the type of ear buds or headphones typically used with phones, they are of relatively well matched sonic quality.

Very good headphones or IEMs might reveal sonic shortcomings of the amp in particular, but the DAC's sonics should also be evident.

Best quality is available in three ways.

One, by using the line out, bypassing the built in amplifier but using the phone's DAC chip.

Two, by bypassing the built-in amplifier with an external amp but using the phone's DAC chip. Unfortunately many third-party portable amps do not use the line out, and instead still go through the built-in amp (anytime you plug into the headphone jack), which is not ideal.

Two, by interfacing with a device that can bypass the phone's built-in DAC chip and use a better quality DAC.
If you go this route, Apple phones offer the best options.

I don't find the built-in DACs of phones to be as bad as some suggest, but certainly using something like an external DAC with ESS Sabre chips (for example; there are others) can offer better sonics, in subtle but noticeable ways. If you are using a good sound system or good IEMs or headphones you should notice an improvement.
 
P

pewternhrata

Audioholic Chief
My note 5 was great, I now have the s8+ and UHQ upscaler has to be turned when using the jack otherwise it's all static. Really frustrated with it.
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top