PS3=$399 or 499. Toshiba recorder/player=$100. I think you can see the answer. To get a better upconverting player, buy one of the HD Toshibas or get an Oppo. Just for giggles, try setting the Toshiba to output 720p, which is your tv's native res. Also, are you using the same connectors, ie HDMI for both or component for both, etc?