The Showdown: Blu-Ray vs. HD-DVD

saurabh

saurabh

Audioholic
March/April 2005

By Michael Grebb


Alan Parsons wishes it wasn't so. But like it or not, the senior vice president of Pioneer's industrial solutions business group has become a wary foot soldier in the battle over the future of the DVD format. As music blares from a band playing at a nearby exhibit at the 2005 International CES, Parsons sits at a small table in a meeting room contemplating how the next couple of years might play out. He remains relatively reserved, trying not to let his passion for the next-generation Blu-Ray Disc format devolve into vitriol against rival format HD-DVD. "I don't like the rock throwing," he insists. "I just want to excite consumers."

That may be true, but Parsons still finds it hard to resist getting in a few digs on the HD-DVD rival, which at about 15 gigabytes per layer has roughly 40 percent less storage capacity than the Blu-Ray format. "They might end up with something ho-hum," he says. "They're saying that [their capacity] is good, but people used to think that five gigs was good enough." Parsons shrugs his shoulders a bit, wearing a look of calm but certain exasperation. "Why would we limit ourselves to a lower capacity?" he asks.

To be sure, Parsons is among several CE manufacturers backing the Blu-Ray format, which they claim is superior to HD-DVD. But the HD-DVD format has its own backers, who while fewer in numbers, are equally adamant that their format will win out because of its lower transition and manufacturing costs—as well as other technical benefits and its expected quicker time to market. Indeed, either format is a vast improvement over the current DVD design, which maxes out at about 4.7 gigabytes. Even at standard-definition quality, that's barely enough space for a two-hour movie and a few hours of special features. And with that much space, forget about high-definition TV.

The benefits for backward compatibility are clear: new players will be able to handle both old and new DVD formats in the same machine (outfitted with both red- and blue-laser diodes)—a major consumer benefit that manufacturers hope will drive unit sales.

Blu-Ray and HD-DVD both use blue lasers... Read on

The complete article can be found here:

http://www.ce.org/publications/vision/2005/marapr/p08.asp

Request administrator to post it fully...

[Edit: Great article! Due to copyright issues I need to limit how much is posted and provide a link to the full article. Thanks. - Clint.]
 
Buckeyefan 1

Buckeyefan 1

Audioholic Ninja
Thanks - not sure if you are aware - this topic has been posted numerous times. Hopefully Blu-Ray wins out.
 
Duffinator

Duffinator

Audioholic Field Marshall
I want my BD DVD

I missed that yesterday, that's really great news. Now if they will pass a 1080i signal over component cables I'll be very, very happy. So it looks like BD DVD format/technology is going to win out, and that means we all win.
 
L

Leprkon

Audioholic General
saurabh said:
I guess nobody wins and truce happens..................read on

Sony, Toshiba to agree on new DVD format -paper
http://www.reuters.co.uk/newsArticle.jhtml;02GY2A1TLC02WCRBAEOCFEY?type=technologyNews&storyID=8431711

Peace breaking out between Blu-ray and HD-DVD
http://www.engadget.com/entry/1234000757042785/
we might be getting Clinton'd here..

email from a friend: was just reading a daily tech newsletter and this was in there

Toshiba, Sony suggest DVD hybrid story better suited for publication in The Onion: Looks like the great Blu-ray/HD DVD compromise is a bit further off than some reports might suggest. This morning, Sony and Toshiba both issued statements disputing a recent report in the Nihon Kiezai Shimbun that the two had agreed on a hybrid high-definition DVD standard. While acknowledging that they are in talks, both companies denied a deal was imminent. "We are actively participating in talks towards format unification," Toshiba's statement said. "At this point, however, nothing has been decided, and absolutely no decision has been made for unification on any basis. The indication that a unification agreement on the basis of a 0.1mm disc system is imminent is unfounded and erroneous." Sony offered a similar denial: "The only true aspect of this report is that Sony, Matsu****a and Toshiba are currently engaged in negotiations."


to quote an X-Wing pilot . .

"Almost there . . . "

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/05/10/toshiba_slams_hd_claims/

http://ps3.ign.com/articles/611/611512p1.html
 
HookedOnSound

HookedOnSound

Full Audioholic
Sony/Toshiba spinoff Format

Oh yip! another half-baked format on the horizon!

Gimme! Gimme! Please!...NOT!

I am sick of the format wars. It's becoming nothing more than Planned Obsolescence.

What's funny is that CD sales have sustained respectable sales volumes (IMHO, partly due to Walmart). I don't buy as many (mainly because the new music comin' out sucks) but I still do.

CDs are widely adopted and have good distribution channels that make it available to consumers. I am willing to bet CD sales will continue to sell for the next 10 years if the vendors keep fighting over format supremacy.

But then again, with all this digital media distribution going on I doubt that the next generation of optical storage will play any serious role like CDs have done.

I just want my cake and eat it too! :)

Is that so much to ask?
 
K

korgoth

Full Audioholic
if you support blue ray you should tell everyone you know to wait

just inform people before they go off buying an hd player, that blue ray is coming out soon and is much better.
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top