Sub decisions! Bic F-12 vs PA-120 vs Lava LSP10

[LeetMiniWheat]

I'm pretty torn between these subs at the moment. my budget is $200ish, $250 TOPS.

1. Premier Acoustic PA-120W 12" $213 shipped
2. LavaSub LSP10 10" $209 shipped
3. Bic Formula F-12 12" $187 shipped (this used to be the H100 I think?)
4. Bic V-1220 12" down firing sub, $167 shipped. (supposed to be a bit tighter than the F12)
5. Acoustic Audio HD-SUB12 12" $189 shipped

I'm expecting a lot from a sub since my Klipsch satellites have poor lows and start at 120Hz, so I'm gonna need a high crossover. I've heard the BIC's don't have good highs and are kinda boomy. Unsure about the Lava and PA-120. the Lava has poor <30Hz i know that much but they are tight/punchy.

I'm mainly looking for a tight/punchy/accurate sub for music, preferably sealed, for a 13x11 room 132sq feet with carpet and a lot of furniture.

Does anyone have a suggestion for one of these or something else? I'm leaning on the PA-120 for $220 shipped which is not a bad deal I think.

 

[LeetMiniWheat]

think I'm gonna get the Lava, I hear the PA-120's are boomy just like the Bic's. Polk PSW505 is also a good contender but the crossover maximum is 125, too low for my satellites.

Edit: done, ordered. incoming buyers remorse

 

[timoteo]

I wouldnt go with any of them. A subwoofer is a very important part of any audio system & can really make or break a setup. A low end speaker set with a decent sub will really improve the overall sound. I recommend being a little patient & saving just a bit more. Then go order an Emotiva 10" sealed sub. You will get such an improved proformance over any of the ones youve listed & you'll be happy you did!!

I looked them up & see they are currently out of stock but they will be back soon, they are a big hit for the price.

Or look up DaytonAudio's reference line. I dont recall their pricing so they may be out of reach for you not sure.

If you can get your budget up another $100-$150 you will start to get into another level of subs that is well worth it. That is the best advice that i can come up with buddy!! Hope it helps...