Some advice please on my first true home theater system

B

Beatmatcher247

Full Audioholic
I asked the only AV show in town to design me a system around $11,000 with everything minus the display if I hook it up and calibrate myself and this is what they recommended and the price including cabling, but no installation.

I want something that will be fairly future ready as far as different formats coming out etc... I like to watch movies as much as I love to listen to music of all varieties (rock, electronic, heavy metal, indy, rap, etc... a wide range). The real problem I have is that in Bismarck, ND there is virtually nowhere aside from Minneapolis I can go to hear anything I'm possibly interested in buying... the guy who quoted me this system did not listen to me when I told him I didn't like the sound of his paradigm monitor series...

7.2 Surround System
Integra DTA70.1
Integra DHC40.2
Integra DBS50.2
Paradigm Monitor11 (1pr)
Paradigm CC390
Paradigm ADP390 (4ea.)
Paradigm UltraCube10 (2ea.)
URC Systems Remote(mx450)
Audioquest Cable package
(includes cables to hookup 2 sources and and a/v components)
Total with Tax $10200

Anyone willing to put together an alternate setup for me? If you are a reputable dealer, I'd certainly buy it from you. Does this sound like an over-bloated price for the above described items? Is the blu-ray player overkill? I don't want to get all this nice stuff and have it sound like crap because I went with a cheap blu-ray unit or something... but I don't want to pay 1700 more than I should have to either.

Anyone know of anywhere in Minneapolis or something with the ability to show you a lot of different options? Winter time is busy for us as far as estimating electrical construction projects so it is hard for me to get away to somewhere I can check a lot of the options out. I know everyone's ears and preferences are different, but I would really really appreciate any advice you can give me. To make a long story, longer, lol, the most important thing to me is sound quality, quality surround processing, and not underpowering my speakers. I don't want any in-wall stuff.

I'm a pretty technical guy I build computers, have experience in telecommunications, am a master electrical contractor... but these receivers-preamps look to have gotten a lot more complicated since my 4-channel, plug in the cd player, and go days, lol... think I can handle it ;p? Would it be worth the money to get a pro to come calibrate things?

PS: I absolutely loath 3-d, so that is not important to me to have that capability. I do want awesome 7.2 channel processing... anyone got a 9.1/9.2 setup going? How do you like it vs. 7.2/7.1
 
M

m_vanmeter

Full Audioholic
may I ask a gentle question ?
why are you risking $11,000 on a "first time" home theater when you seem very uncertain about what you want/need and have not gained the knowledge yet to truly evaluate the offers you will receive ? You would not do this with an IT installation or major electrical job !

you are "chumming the water with a pile of dollar bills" and the sharks are invited to eat you alive ! :confused:
 
N

Nestor

Senior Audioholic
If there's one advice I can give you, find out how much you are being fleeced with the Audioquest cables, and take that off the price.
 
B

Beatmatcher247

Full Audioholic
may I ask a gentle question ?
why are you risking $11,000 on a "first time" home theater when you seem very uncertain about what you want/need and have not gained the knowledge yet to truly evaluate the offers you will receive ? You would not do this with an IT installation or major electrical job !

you are "chumming the water with a pile of dollar bills" and the sharks are invited to eat you alive ! :confused:
Very true, and a fair question. 11k is what I decided I want to spend... to get it done right the first time. I don't want to make any missteps on this thing but I really don't know where to begin. I've looked at a lot of different systems online, and read thousands of reviews, but it doesn't tell me anything about how it will sound to me. I'm willing to try what some of you folks who've been around the home theater block a few times might suggest for this price range or even less... I don't have to spend that much.. but I want to spend enough to be sure I'll be happy with it.

From what I understand, the quotation they gave me is for pretty much full msrp on everything and I know I can do better than that. Anyone able to recommend someone that would be willing to design something that won't take advantage of me for being unknowledgeable about what I'm buying? Or like a home theater store that has the capability and inventory to show a lot of different setups? How do I get the knowledge without a lot of costly mistakes to acquire it?

When unknowledgeable people come to me for something, I treat them like I would like to be treated, and they almost always come back. Anyone know anyone good to work with in the Minneapolis area?
 
sholling

sholling

Audioholic Ninja
Hopefully someone can help you because I hate to see a dealer try to finance the family's Hawaiian vacation on the back of one or two sales. From my layman's point of view what sticks out is that you're rushing into something that shouldn't be rushed. The problem as you know is that speakers are very subjective choices and what I like you may hate. Also different speakers do different things well and speakers that we both love for music might not meet your needs for an action movie fix. My advice is to slow down and do some legwork and a whole bunch of research before writing that check. Members smarter than me can give you some great speaker ideas but you're going to have to figure out a way to audition them for yourself to see if they match your taste. That's not always as hard as you think because some smaller internet direct companies have loyal customers that will open their homes for auditions. Salk is one of those but there are others. Make a list of candidates and check their forums for volunteers within driving range.

Once you've figured out your speaker solution you can start thinking about amplifiers. There is simply no use buying (for example) a 150wpc amp only to discover that it doesn't have enough power for your new speakers or buying a 500wpc amp when the speakers that you finally fall in love with will only handle 150w. Select speakers and then the electronics.
 
B

Beatmatcher247

Full Audioholic
That's really cool that there are some people willing to show their setups for their dealers. Never even thought that could be an option. This message board is a great community.
 
AVRat

AVRat

Audioholic Ninja
What are the dimensions of the room? I also noticed that that budget doesn't take into account room treatments which can really help with bad room acoustics. What display type will you be using, TV, PJ/screen (size)?

$11K sounds like a lot, but it can sure go quick!:eek:
 
B

Beatmatcher247

Full Audioholic
Display: 65" Panasonic: TC-P65S2 (Best non-3d plasma I'm aware of, and I like the picture a lot. I really liked the Pioneer elite plasma when it came out except I didn't like the $7,000 price tag lol. The picture on this tv reminds me a lot of those sets and they supposedly have purchased rights to pioneers plasma technology).

The Room: I'm also in the process of purchasing my first home, so I have no idea yet what I'm going to end up with for sure as far as dimensions/acoustics. I'll post some dimensions/pictures when I have an accepted offer in on something. It won't be a really large room.

Sorry for all of the unknowns.
 
sholling

sholling

Audioholic Ninja
The Room: I'm also in the process of purchasing my first home, so I have no idea yet what I'm going to end up with for sure as far as dimensions/acoustics. I'll post some dimensions/pictures when I have an accepted offer in on something. It won't be a really large room.
Which kind of leaves any integrator shaking their heads because without a nailed down room size and configuration (sealed room or open plan) there really isn't any way to guess at your needs and thus no reason to spend the time to sharpen the pencil on the quote.

What I'd do is spend some time deciding on priorities such as dynamics vs musical fidelity (or as I usually describe it as the Church of Dynamics! vs the Church of Flat & Musical because it's a religious issue for many ;)). I'm a fence sitter. Listen to examples of each and decide where you are and then start listening more critically and searching for the one puts a grin on your face.
 
J

jostenmeat

Audioholic Spartan
Display: 65" Panasonic: TC-P65S2 (Best non-3d plasma I'm aware of, and I like the picture a lot. I really liked the Pioneer elite plasma when it came out except I didn't like the $7,000 price tag lol. The picture on this tv reminds me a lot of those sets and they supposedly have purchased rights to pioneers plasma technology).

The Room: I'm also in the process of purchasing my first home, so I have no idea yet what I'm going to end up with for sure as far as dimensions/acoustics. I'll post some dimensions/pictures when I have an accepted offer in on something. It won't be a really large room.

Sorry for all of the unknowns.
IMO, that package is an utter ripoff. BTW, the S2 is not even close to the best plasma even just within Panasonic's lineup.

Start with the speakers and subs first. Read read read.

Drop Audioquest, COMPLETELY. Get all of your stuff from Monoprice. I just saved you a grand. You're welcome.

After speakers are chosen, can you start looking for electronics.

Then I would do automation at the very end.

What's sorta dumb about doing automation to begin with is that you won't even know what your stuff can do. You will be completely dependent on the installer to even know what these things can do (and I know CI guys who don't know squat!!!) let alone explain these things to you. Work with the original remotes, for say several months, then you'll know which functions/settings you want for any given application, and THEN you can have your remote programmed.
 
BMXTRIX

BMXTRIX

Audioholic Warlord
Display: 65" Panasonic: TC-P65S2 (Best non-3d plasma I'm aware of, and I like the picture a lot.
The Panasonic VT25 series is the BEST plasma on the market. Drop the 3D hate, and focus on the single quality of the display. If it offers 3D, then don't count it against the display! Just ignore it as something you are taking into consideration. If you do this, you will find that the VT25 series 65" Panasonic is the best display on the market this year. Of course, you still will want to be viewing in a room without a lot of lights behind you.

You may also want to consider front projection and a 100"+ screen depending on your room setup.

The Room: I'm also in the process of purchasing my first home, so I have no idea yet what I'm going to end up with for sure as far as dimensions/acoustics. I'll post some dimensions/pictures when I have an accepted offer in on something. It won't be a really large room.
Getting a system before you have a room is terrible. You really have no idea what is appropriate, but I would personally not go with Integra as they are the 'upper end' brand from Onkyo. In my experience, Onkyo packs a lot of features into their products, but has the worst build quality and engineering of any of the major manufacturers. Denon is way up there in overall quality, and Yamaha and Pioneer are definite considerations. But, on a serious budget, Emotiva would be on my list for sure.

The remote is pretty basic for such a high end room, which leaves me a bit irritated as you should want it all easy for your family to use and not just yourself.

Finally, the Oppo series of Blu-ray players are the best on the market, but even some of the cheaper models, such as the Panasonic DMP-BD65 (about $100) will provide top shelf audio because Blu-ray natively is a top shelf product. Spending more than the Oppo is money wasted.

http://www.oppodigital.com/blu-ray-bdp-93/

http://www.emotiva.com

The brand name cables are likely money wasted as well. Sticking with quality cables, regardless of brand name, can go a long way to making your system shine without a lot of money.

Don't forget that you need a place to put all this gear, so your equipment rack may need to be a part of this budget.

$11,000 affords a nice setup, but when I hear a budget like that I'm usually providing a full 7.1 setup, with a projector, a screen, and a Crestron control system to make it all work... Fully installed.
 
B

Beatmatcher247

Full Audioholic
I guess the main reason I'm steering away from 3d, is two reasons. First the price is almost 2x as much as a compareable non-3d model, and 3d gives me migraines so bad that make me want to check out early. Surely there are great 65" plasma displays I can get that don't do 3d, no? I'm not opposed to having a display that does 3-D, just the sticker price on the front of it.

What you guys have said about the package they are recommending confirms my suspicions that they are trying to bone me bad on this thing.. I've also talked with some people who've had work done by this outfit and they weren't at all happy with either the quality of installation, the calibration/optimization or how knowledgeable the technicians were about their products.

At this point, I'm going to go hear as much different stuff as possible from as many manufacturers as possible to try and get a better idea of what I am going to be happy with. And of course, before I give you guys an aneurism trying to figure out what to put in a mystery room :D , I will buy a house so I can fill in some more of the unknowns here.

The suggestion to bring along some of your own music and blu-rays is a great one. I might drive from Bismarck to Minneapolis this weekend to hear some different offerings that aren't carried here.

Bmxtrix, could you give me an example of a 11k installed setup you have put together for a customer?
 
J

jostenmeat

Audioholic Spartan
I guess the main reason I'm steering away from 3d, is two reasons. First the price is almost 2x as much as a compareable non-3d model, and 3d gives me migraines so bad that make me want to check out early. Surely there are great 65" plasma displays I can get that don't do 3d, no? I'm not opposed to having a display that does 3-D, just the sticker price on the front of it.
Listen, I am just like you in that I don't care about 3D. I think it looks terrible and contrived, for what I've seen. I think 2D Avatar in my HT annihilates the 3D version for example.

That said, BMX has likened 3D to many other types of features with our stuff; it will be an included feature no matter what. For example, I would say 99% of us here don't care for video processing in a receiver, yet 99% have this no matter what; it's simply included.

SO, some of the other reasons to get a VT25? Well, the biggest for me is that it's the only Pana plasma that can properly display 24p. Since I watch 99% bluray, this is huge. It will also have THX mode, and this mode will always be the most color accurate mode on a display, and thus will always be the starting point for any pro calibrator. Even without pro calibration and SM offsets, the VT25 will offer more consumer level pic controls. I cannot recall, but if I had to blindly bet, I bet the glass/panel is probably superior to the S2 maybe with a better AR filter, but I'm not sure as I forget these things (I've never bought a flat panel).

What you guys have said about the package they are recommending confirms my suspicions that they are trying to bone me bad on this thing.. I've also talked with some people who've had work done by this outfit and they weren't at all happy with either the quality of installation, the calibration/optimization or how knowledgeable the technicians were about their products.
This is either the funny or sad part, they might not even know they are ripping you off. Many CI guys (and I'm NOT talking about people here like BMX or highfigh who give you high value in order that the customer have great satisfaction) just look at the dollars, look at it as a job, and are not so passionate about it.

At this point, I'm going to go hear as much different stuff as possible from as many manufacturers as possible to try and get a better idea of what I am going to be happy with. And of course, before I give you guys an aneurism trying to figure out what to put in a mystery room :D , I will buy a house so I can fill in some more of the unknowns here.
W/ or W/o medical conditions, the room is BY FAR the most important thing. It decides the allocation of budget, the flexibility and/or limitations of said expenditures, and will have THE greatest impact on both video and audio. After the room, the most important purchases respectively are the display and speakers (after all they are what *finally* convert electrical signals into the visible light and sound that you can finally detect with your human senses; this is where the greatest distortions and/or errors will lie).

Bmxtrix, could you give me an example of a 11k installed setup you have put together for a customer?
If it was me, I'd get a JVC HD250 for 2.5k, built a Seymour CenterStage XD screen for about $300 total, build three speakers for less than $1000 that compare to (high value) $6000 speakers having them hidden behind the screen. BTW, the ideal center speaker is vertically arrayed, identical to main speakers, on the same plane. Best match, best horiz dispersion, even height means best panning possible. Of course, that's easier said than done, and I myself have just got my feet wet last year.

Anyways, we need to know about the room. Also, since 11k is not unlimited, it depends on what the customer wants. Some want the best video, some want the best speakers, some want ridiculous bass, some want high level automation (I would say that's what is most important to most well-off consumers, the automation, but they're not so passionate nor knowledgeable about AV).
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top