RPTV vs. Flat Panel?

S

sanoel

Enthusiast
Is there any difference between these 2 types of Tv's? Besides size.
I know you have different technologies, each having there pros and cons, but is the a difference say between a LCD RPTV and a LCD Flat Panel?
 
sts9fan

sts9fan

Banned
Yeah theres a difference. One is a rear projection while the other is not. If you care about a quality picture imho the rp sets are better.
 
S

sanoel

Enthusiast
so the RPTV have a better quality picture than the Flat panels? Dont know why i was thinking it was the other way around.
 
W

westcott

Audioholic General
sanoel said:
Is there any difference between these 2 types of Tv's? Besides size.
I know you have different technologies, each having there pros and cons, but is the a difference say between a LCD RPTV and a LCD Flat Panel?
Here is a link that discusses the pros and cons of each.
I prefer flat panel to rear projection. RPTV's sales will slow as flat panel prices continue to fall.

http://www.hdtvsolutions.com/big_picture_main.htm

My favorite display is front projection for largest picture\dollar.:cool:
 
C

clayman88

Junior Audioholic
It also depends on what size of tv you're looking for. Typically the RPTV's are much larger while still maintaining high quality video, while the flat panels are not able to be quite as large. However, this is changing as new flat panel technologies are being developed.

Also, remember that the DLP's & LCOS's require a bulb that will have to be changed every year or two depending on how much its used. These bulbs can cost anywhere from 200-300 bucks. As far as which has better quality, that is a heavily debated topic and its best to leave that decision to your own eyes. Hope that helps. :)
 
GlocksRock

GlocksRock

Audioholic Spartan
And don't forget that rptv's will have to be reconverged from time to time which isn't free either.
 
jonnythan

jonnythan

Audioholic Ninja
GlocksRock said:
And don't forget that rptv's will have to be reconverged from time to time which isn't free either.
That's only RP CRT's.. the old style gigantic boxes. Newer RP LCD's and DLP's do not need this.
 
W

westcott

Audioholic General
The biggest disadvantage, besides space consumed, of RP is the off axis viewing. There is just too much change in picture quality as you move about the room, sitting or standing.
 
BMXTRIX

BMXTRIX

Audioholic Warlord
Rear projection is tougher off-axis and has the long term cost of replacement lamps that may be necessary. There also is the concern of the moving parts or burnt panels within any projection technology - but not enough of a worry that I would consider it major. RPTV (new digital formats, not CRT) don't suffer from burn in and give you a sharp image which is plenty bright enough in most rooms. Great for gaming or general TV viewing. Plus, you can get very large sizes without jumping a ton in money, though, IMO, smaller sizes tend to be far more than they should be.

Flat panel displays (FPDs) still take up far less room, they really are designed to incorporate into your room seamlessly. When combined with in-wall or on-wall speakers and IR repeaters they become as much a lifestyle statement as they are a piece of A/V gear. They tend to be very good from any angle - plasmas especially - and can be turned on/off very quickly instead of having warm up times or cool down periods. No replacement lamps... and they tend to last 20+ years with normal usage.

But, plasma, if you aren't somewhat cautious, can suffer from burn-in which is at least a bit of a concern if you play a lot of video games and aren't aware of the potential. Flat LCDs do NOT suffer from burn-in but some consider their pixel refresh speed to be a bit slow which can cause some blurring with faster action.

Most of all, as sizes get larger and larger, prices tend to get very high on these products, very quickly. This year we are finally seeing 50" panels drop below $3,000... But, 60" models are still very pricey.

Finally, neither technology is as solid as the old style CRT displays. Color and black levels from CRT simply are the gold standard that have not been met by any of the new digital technologies... yet. SED panels which may be out late this year... maybe... are rumoured to be much closer to CRT in image quality, but similar to a plasma in design. Hang it on the wall - have a great image.

Personally? I've gone with plasma for my displays right now along with front projection. Plasma is just great for day-to-day viewing and being able to hang it on the wall above a dresser or behing a electric screen makes it blend well into my home environment. The rooms where it doesn't matter as much I hang some old CRTs from the ceiling.
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top