Turntables have to be obsessionally set up or they sound awful.
You need the correct tracking force. That should be set towards the top end of manufacturers recommended range.
The over hang to minimize tracking error is a very important adjustment. You can download a protractor for doing this from vinyl engine.
Setting the correct tracking angle is important.
Setting the antiskate correctly is also desirable.
If the arm allows it, and a lot don't, getting the azimuth right is also important to minimize record wear.
I find most users don't set up their turntables properly at all. They think they sound great, when in fact they are downright awful.
I would also not use a USB output for what you want to play. I would use a good RIAA input, or a phono pre amp if you do not have a phono input on your rig.
I would recommend
this cartridge as a replacement.
Second choice would
be this one.
I have used both for people and have a definite preference for the Shure.