Popcorn Hour vs iStar vs TVIX HD-m6500A

G

giyad

Enthusiast
I am in the process of setting up my home theater. I currently have a TV, and I have a Receiver in mind as well.

I have: Samsung LN-46A750
Want to get: Yamaha RX-V663

I'm going to connect my TV to receiver via HDMI. Then I want to hook up my content (ripped movies, music, photos, etc..) to my TV. I was thinking about an HTPC, but that route seems to be expensive and probably not worth the effort.

So, I'm thinking now about getting either:

1) Popcorn Hour with a PVR (most likely the Hauppage, or possibly GB-PVR)
2) iStar mini with a PVR as well, same set up as above most likely.
3) TVIX HD-M6500A with a TV Tuner to record and pause cable.

Now they all have their pros and cons, so I want you guys to help me decide if you can.

Here are some of the pros/cons I found per device.

Popcorn Hour
Pros: Its got internal storage (sold separately). Plays all formats, and HD content. Small, small carbon footprint. Good forums and updates are frequent.
Cons: Internal storage is IDE and there is no SATA... There is also no way to record and pause unless getting an external PVR. The main thing though is I hear the UI is crap, and if your putting an internal hard drive some people have had heat issues.

iStar
Pros: Plays all formats, and HD. Tiniest of the devices. Takes eSATA devices for external storage.
Cons: Storage is external. No PVR.

TVIX M6500A
Pros: Plays all formats, and HD. Nice LCD. Good remote. Takes eSATA. Can buy a TV Tuner to record and pause. Good UI!!
Cons: External storage.

What do you guys think?
 
J

jamie2112

Banned
Tvix would be my pick of the litter of those 3 you listed.
 
J

jamie2112

Banned
I also think Apple TV is another route to go if you have a Mac.
 
M

mirkanos

Audiophyte
Hdmi 1.3

Hi!

I think u are forgetting one thing, ISTAR have HDMI 1.3 ans Popcorn HDMI 1.1.
I dont know if this question is important. Anybody knows?
 
M

mirkanos

Audiophyte
Apple TV??!?

Apple TV????????'

xDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

Please...
 
G

giyad

Enthusiast
Hi!

I think u are forgetting one thing, ISTAR have HDMI 1.3 ans Popcorn HDMI 1.1.
I dont know if this question is important. Anybody knows?
1.3 supports HD audio formats while 1.1 does not. I don't think it makes a big difference though...
 
W

waldenlima

Audiophyte
Tvix is good, this is the first choice for you. but a little expensive.

Another choice you can check LimHD 360s or 310s from Tomacro,
Looks also nice, but cheap, you can google it.
 
W

waldenlima

Audiophyte
looks this thread also have been released in AVS, right?
 
G

giyad

Enthusiast
haha, yeah sorry i posted it on a couple of forums, AVS had the most particpation
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top