Plugging speaker ports...any harm?

P

pearsall001

Full Audioholic
Just a question out of curiousity. Some speaker designs are sealed & others are ported. Now granted, the designer had specific goals in mind for their performance by choising one of the two designs. What is the real difference between the two? Does a ported speaker provide more bass than a sealed speaker? Does one design perform better than the other, & if you were to stuff the port holes how would it effect the speakers performance? Could that possible harm the speaker? I think it's all about moving air inside the cabinet. In a sealed design where does the air go or maybe it doesn't. I guess either design has it's +/-. Any thoughts?
 
zildjian

zildjian

Audioholic Chief
A speaker installed in a sealed enclosure has the air inside the enclosure acting as a suspension, like a spring, often referred to as an "air suspension" to help provide recoil force for the movement of the diaphragm. Ported enclosures (bass reflex) also can have the air inside act as a spring as long as the hole in the box is small enough to provide enough resistance to the movement of the air. This design is more efficient for bass reproduction. The air in the enclosure will be able to move enough to resonate within the enclosure, the resonate freqency depends on the diameter, length & shape of the port, and size and shape of the box, which all yield the cumulative effect of determining the acoustic properties the air within the enclosure. The speaker driver and tuning of the port must coincide properly so as the tuning of the port will have an additive effect of increased bass output at the proper freqencies. At other frequencies the port can be tuned to provide more resistance and provide dampening to the woofer. This is a pretty complex relationship that can be easily done improperly yielding freq response curves that are laughable, but if done properly, can give a lot of bank for the buck. I don't want to go into too much detail as there are books out there that would explain this far better than I could, but hopefully this helps a little. As far as would plugging the port hurt the speaker, doubtful, but if the speaker was properly engineered, plugging the port would result in the woofer not responding as intended over certain freqencies, so I doubt it would sound better, again that is assuming the speaker was engineered properly.
Brad
 
J

Joe Schmoe

Audioholic Ninja
I wouldn't say that either ported or sealed is inherently better. Both have tradeoffs. The designer, however, makes that decision and then chooses all the other parameters accordingly. Second-guessing the designer by plugging the ports is not likely to improve the sound, and may make it worse. (One exception is B&W, who include port plugs with some of their models, and suggest using them if the speakers will be placed near a wall.)
 
Z

zumbo

Audioholic Spartan
How about this.

Don't plug the hole.

Only plug the hole if the manufacture provides the approved plug.

I don't know much about speaker design, but I do know there are different driver designs for each application.
 
annunaki

annunaki

Moderator
Zumbo is correct.

Unless of course you call the manufacturer and it is approved through tech support. Even then I would make sure I get the tech's name...
should there be a problem.
 
skizzerflake

skizzerflake

Audioholic Field Marshall
You didn't say why you wanted to plug the hole but, don't. The speaker was designed with a port to enhance bass and efficiency. If you plug the port, you will lose that bass and gain nothing. It will probably do no damage except to the performance of the speakers.
 

baseman

Enthusiast
A woofer in an acoustic suspension cabinet usually has a weaker surround because it is literally supported by the air in the cabinet. If you cut a port in the cab the speaker could shake itself to death, or overextend itself causing mechanical failure....a torn surround, spyder or voice coil rub.
 
Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
baseman said:
A woofer in an acoustic suspension cabinet usually has a weaker surround because it is literally supported by the air in the cabinet. If you cut a port in the cab the speaker could shake itself to death, or overextend itself causing mechanical failure....a torn surround, spyder or voice coil rub.
Very true, but the OP wanted to know if it was a good idea to seal a ported speaker.
 

baseman

Enthusiast
Seth=L said:
Very true, but the OP wanted to know if it was a good idea to seal a ported speaker.
Correct, I should have included that it was a bad idea although for similar but opposite reasons. It would tend to stifle an already stiffly suspended driver, in addition to throwing all the designers carefully thought out work right out the window. :(
 
Jack Hammer

Jack Hammer

Audioholic Field Marshall
It may help if you list the speaker brand and model #. As mentioned, some speakers are designed so the port can be plugged, some are not. The ones that are designed to allow plugging do so to allow more options for the speakers intended use - plugging the port if using speaker with a subwoofer, unplug it if you are not, or to help adjust for corner placement. If the port is
not designed for use while plugged performance will likely suffer and damage may occur.

Jack
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top