I like the article up to a point.
What I don't like, is that I really feel that every projector needs to be rated on how it actually stands up against projectors that people may be considering for home theater use. In this regard, cheap DLP projectors tend to have limited throw range and no lens shift.
This means that their setup is fixed, and is not at all 'easy' or 'ergonomic' - both scores which rated 5 stars. Typically, a projector with very limited lens options is, at best, average, but compared to what is out there, especially in home theater, for a few bucks more, this lack of zoom and lens shift should put the projector well under 'average'.
The zoom range on this particular model is 1.1 to 1 which means that if you have a 100" diagonal (4x3) image, the projector may only sit about 13 to 14 feet from the screen. If your couch is there? Oh well, just move it forward and live with what it is!
Not exactly usable or friendly for many.
If the results are specific to comparitive 'boardroom' type projectors, I would agree, that it is 'average'. I have seen a couple dozen different boardroom projectors in the past few months, and they all look so similar it's amazing. Really, does this one stand out in that regard?
I just don't imaging how a non-HD, 4x3 projector, with poor handling of HD material, actually rates FOUR stars overall on a home A/V website. Value? Even there - for the same money you have several true HD projection units available.