Ignore power ratings on loudspeakers. They are near-meaningless.
Important loudspeaker specifications * are efficiency and to a certain extent, impedance and phase characteristics. The rest is mostly just marketing doublespeak.
If you know the efficiency, then you can determine how much power you need to drive them to the desired Sound Pressure Level (SPL) (means "how loud"). That is how you choose electronics to mate with the existing speakers you have.
There is virtually no difference between 90 and 100 watts output into the same loudspeaker. In order to play twice as loud (2x) you need 10x the amplifier power. A +11% difference (1.1x) is measurable but nearly inaudible.
If the new receiver doesn't sound as loud as the old, it's almost certainly due to some other reason. Now, you say you aren't an audio guy and watts and ohms confuse you. It may well be that you are misreading the output power of the new receiver, and if so, then there could be an issue based on power output. If you can offer the model numbers of the old and new, it would make it easier to determine if in fact that's the case.
* Naturally, Sound Quality (SQ) is important, but you evaluate that by listening, not reading.