Maybe I'm a bit spoiled for a kicker who 99% of the time gets the job done.
Sure the Jets offense was all but non-existant, but the Steelers, a 15-1 team, could do no better than match the Jets score. In a defensive game, when the score is tied, with only seconds left, you generally expect a kicker to come in and put it away. Regardless of his pay, that is his job.