Interesting. So you knew which components were playing each time.
You're getting ahead of yourself and it's primarily my fault. I had to cut my response short because my three year old awoke crying and saying his mouth hurt. So I submitted the post and went to take care of my son.
He bit his tongue in his sleep and he was hurting with it for a while. By the time we got him back to sleep, I was sleepy and had no interest in thinking and posting, any more....lol.
Okay, back to the subject at hand.
No, we didn't know which was which. There was four of us. Three of us did a majority of the listening, while the other guy switched cables and components.
We kept the Mac MC252 amp on the bottom shelf because it weighs a little over 100 lbs. And none of us can get involved in moving an amp of that size around, several times.
The Van Alstine Fet Valve 500 was placed on the floor, on the side of the rack.
The Rega Saturn on the top shelf of the rack and C220 preamp on the second shelf.
The Marantz PM8003 on third shelf. The Rega Saturn and Marantz SA8003 and PM8003 were the only components that needed tio be physically switched in and out. The rest of the components just required cables being switched.
I have a large four panel decorative screen (hardwood frame, completely upolstored in thick fabric and some kind of polyfill). We used that to completely sheild the components, from our view. Only the one guy made all the changes. And we left the room and went on my front porch every time any changes were made.
My buddy ( the one doing all the switching) brought his SPL and he made sure the levels were consistent.
Two of us prefered the Mac gear. The other guy prefered the Van Alstine.
The guy doing all the switching prefered the Mac gear, too. But he knew what was what, so I'm sure that won't account for much, for you.
Over a period of about threem months (when we had the free time), we did the same thing with the Jamo C607, C807 and C809. As we did with the C803.
It's indisputable that to our ears, the Mac combo and Van Alstine combo were a huge improvement in every aspect; over the Marantz combo. And they should be.
That's not me slamming or bashing the Marantz gear. It's nice gear at it's price point. But the differences and improvements are immediately audible with the Mac and VA.
The truth is, I really wanted to like the Marantz gear. Let's face it, it's much less expensive than the Mac and VA gear

And my intentions have always been to get the best quality sound, for the least possible cost.
When I first started auditioning Jamo speakers ....IIRC, back in late 2008; I auditioned a lot of different speakers in all different catagories.
I started with the Jamo C607 floorstanders and compared them to a lot of speakers.......Including the Vienna Acoustics Bach Grand, VA Mozart Grand, Polk Audio RTi A9 (and the RTi A7 and RTi A5 ), two Energy speakers (don't recall which floorstanding models they were), Wharfedale Evo 30, some Revel floorstander model and a few others (would have to find my notebook to recall model number).
Yet, I ended up going with the Jamo C607, which are much less expensive than any of those other speakers. Because to my ears, all those other speakers didn't beat the Jamo C607 and didn't deliver the kind of sound I like. From there, I went on to get all the other Jamo speakers I mentioned up above.
I know what I like in sound and my ears tell me all I need to know.
I absolutely respect and believe in the science of audio. But all gear does not sound the same, whether it be speakers.....amps.....pre amps or sources.
There's a lot that are very identical and almost imposible to hear a difference. But there's a lot that absolutely sound different.......better....worse....more melodic and more sterile.
Just like I my ears tell me what the B & W 802 are allo about.
Like I said, this wasn't a slight, vague difference and improvement. It is a veru audible improvement and difference.
Of course you and everyone else can and will believe what you want to believe.