Hi rolyasm.
I don't think splitting the signal is the issue, its the lenght of the cable run and you supplied no distances.
Assuming that the total lenght of the cable run from receiver to rear sub will be longer than 30 feet (and as someone already posted), I would use 1 splitter at the receiver sub/pre output. Then run a cable to the 2 front subs. Then a cable from each of the line level (RCA connector) outputs to the rear subs, same side of room. This is the daisy chaining method described in a previous post.
If your subs do not have a line level ouput, then use a splitter at each of the front subs and run a cable back to the rear sub, same room side. If the rear subs don't sound exactly the same as the front subs with the volume level set the same on all subs, then you will need a ditribution amp like a previous poster suggested.
If for some reason none of the above works, then I suggest that you move the rear subs to the sides of the room or make 2 stacks of 2 subs each at the front of the room. You can't try stacking if you have downfiring subs. Also, I have read, but never tried, placing 2 subs side by side(sides touching) to achieve the same synergystic effect that stacking affords (increased SPL). This, of course, can be done w/ downfiring subs.
Mike
Mike