S

Sasha

Audiophyte
After spending several months at various stores and comparing flat panel HDTVs, I think (I hope) I managed to narrow my choice down to two sets, Sharp 37” LCD LC37GB5U and Pioneer 43” plasma PDP4340HD.
It is nearly impossible to decide what to go with, PQ varies significantly on the same model from store to store, but it seems these two sets cannot be a miss.
IMO Sharp has better resolution, but lacks something that Pioneer delivers, I cannot say what it is, but appears to be more natural and more vibrant colors (probably due to better contrast), and more dimensional picture.
But then again, I may have been misled by inconsistent signal delivery to both sets.
If you were in my shoes, which one would you purchase?
Or would you dismiss both sets and go with something else in this price range?
:confused:
 
brian32672

brian32672

Banned
Front projection DLP, only way to go. With a minimum of a 100" screen.......
 
av-man

av-man

Audioholic
Not a big fan of LCD but the Pioneer is a nice set. I would look at LG. I just sold a LG DU42PX12X and I was really impressed with the set.
 
S

Sasha

Audiophyte
Is not LG DU42PX12X an old model that does not support HDCP?
 
BMXTRIX

BMXTRIX

Audioholic Warlord
I would go with the Pioneer any day of the week over the Sharp. LCD is not as good with motion and the contrast ratio totally kills it. Sharp, in my experience, has some terrible engineers that learn about problems, then don't correct them. Things can be an issue for YEARS - without being resolved. They are just disinterested in improving their own products to make them work better - and I would not recommend any company that feels that way about a product we buy.

Pioneer on the other hand is somewhat responsive, but has good engineers so you don't need to call about issues anyway. Their plasmas are some of the best that I have ever seen with incredible blacks and shadow detail. If I were to buy a nice plasma, it would almost definitely be a Pioneer.

Unless I had a pitch black room to setup a DLP front projector... Holy hijack a thread brian! :)
 
brian32672

brian32672

Banned
BMXTRIX said:
Unless I had a pitch black room to setup a DLP front projector... Holy hijack a thread brian! :)
Thanks for the vote of confidence.

But, I do not live in a totally dark condo. Where the projector is setup. Actually room has two sliding glass doors. With only white shades on each window in all rooms. Also there are days when sun is blarring in the room, as long as this direct light is off of the screen it does not matter. Meaning, that sun comes in from behind the screen and lights up the room. At night, I can turn all lights on, and still comfortably watch TV/DVD movies.

To get a decent picture from a projector in a daylit room, there are 2 options. Either you get a screen with a higher gain level above a 1.0 gain (depending on amount of light). Or get a DLP projector with a decent amount of lumens, say about 2000 or more. My friend with a 700 lumen and 100" screen, has seen pictures of my screen during the day. And says he must get a projector with more lumens. Because mine can be seen during the day, perfectly fine. However even a low lumen, say 700 lumens on a smaller screen between 50" to 60" would easily produce a image that could be watched during the day. Bigger the screen, the farther the projector must be back.

Trade off is, with a screen with higher gain levels (above 2.0+) you will have less of an angle (over 60 degrees) with optimum perception. But usually this does not matter as screen takes up a big part of the wall. So you would be seeing the picture in most cases as if you were in front of the picture.
Basically anywhere you sit in a room would be like a movie theater, and you could see picture just fine.
With both of my screens of 1.0 gain, I have even taken pictures of the screen (with movie playing) at a 90 degree angle. And there is no loss of picture quality. Granted, I had to go into the next room to get this angle. Screens I have are a 96" DaLite Manual screen, the other is Elite 120" Remote controlled screen.

Unlike a rear projection tv, that even a 10 degree angle on a quality tv would lose picture quality. At 20+ degrees, why even bother watching it.

There are a lot of bars going with front projection, watching Baseball games during the day with plenty of windows. If set up correctly, it can be seen by the entire bar during the day. I suggest checking out the local sport bars.

Either way, I am sure your decision will be fine. Once you go large screen, theres no turning back to even a 36" screen. :)
 
Last edited:
WooHoo

WooHoo

Audioholic
You've spent several months doing your research and have it down to 2? Pull out a quarter, throw it up in the air..... :rolleyes:
 
av-man

av-man

Audioholic
sasha,
You're right it was the 42PX12XC. I don't know if it has been replaced yet. I installed it about 3 weeks ago.
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top