Help choosing DVD player

B

bleonard24

Audiophyte
My wife and I are in the market for a new DVD player, and I'm not sure how much we should spend or what would fit best into the system we have. We have a Yamaha htr-5890 reciever, 7.1, no HDMI; and a Sony KDS-R60XBR1 TV, inputs galore.

My biggest concern is in being able to play HD DVDs when they start coming out, and getting the best display/sound from the DVDs out now.

Right now, we're ready to spend up to $400 on a new DVD player. We could wait a month or two and up that to $1000. Any suggestions?

Other Qestions: Am I really missing out by not having HDMI on the reciever? Can I run HDMI straight from the DVD player to the TV and still have the sound through the reciever? Will the Playstation III, when it comes out, have the DVD playback quality I'm looking for? (Fry's salesman told me it would.)

Thanks! Any info would be appreciated :)
 
brian32672

brian32672

Banned
Personally, I would wait until there are way more than 4 movies to choose from.:rolleyes:

Give it at least a month/maybe 2. (or at least until there are at least 50 titles to choose from)
(that's just my opinion)

As far as your HDMI question, yep, that is perfectly fine.
Run it straight to the tv, and just have a digital optical/or/coax to the receiver.

This was just posted 3 hours ago in the Seattle Times paper.


"HD-DVD discs, players arrive — in small dose
By Victor Godinez

The Dallas Morning News

DALLAS — The high-definition DVD era begins today with the official launch in the United States of HD-DVD movie players and discs.

Don't expect much fanfare — only two players ($499 and $799 Toshiba models) and four movies are available.

And the arrival of a competing format known as Blu-ray is a little over a month away.

But there are hopeful signs for electronics makers and movie studios that HD-DVD or Blu-ray could eventually be a hit with consumers.

The biggest boost for the new formats will be that sales of high-definition televisions — a necessity to take full advantage of high-def movies — are booming.

The total number of HDTVs sold in the United States is expected to surpass standard television sales this year.

No one expects HD-DVD or Blu-ray to be an overnight sensation.

Blockbuster will offer the first batch of HD-DVD movies only through its online rental service, not in its stores. Available today are "Serenity," "The Last Samurai," "Million Dollar Baby" and "The Phantom of the Opera."

"I think with the consumer penetration for high-definition players being really limited at [first], it would have made it really difficult to roll it out nationally in our stores," said spokesman Randy Hargrove.

He said Blockbuster probably will take a similar approach with Blu-ray movies, which are scheduled to arrive on May 23.


One reason firms are being cautious is that HD-DVD and Blu-ray are incompatible formats.

You can't watch HD-DVD movies using a Blu-ray player, and vice versa, and anyone who ends up investing in the losing format will be stuck with obsolete technology.

As a result, many consumers could sit on their wallets until a clear winner emerges.

Electronics retailer Best Buy will sell HD-DVD movies and players in its stores starting today, and will do the same with Blu-ray when that technology becomes available.

But in a statement, it said, "Best Buy believes that one format will live and one will die."

The higher cost of movies and heavy-handed anti-piracy measures could dissuade others from buying into high-definition DVDs.

On BestBuy.com, for example, the regular DVD version of "The Last Samurai" is listed at $9.99. The HD-DVD version costs $24.99.

To limit piracy, disc publishers can choose to scale back the video quality when players are connected to HD televisions with less-secure component cables, rather than the latest HDMI cables.

Many older high-def televisions don't have HDMI inputs.

Still, the market is clearly growing for high-definition video.

According to the Consumer Electronics Association, 33.2 million televisions were shipped in the United States last year."

Link to that article - http://seattletimes.nwsource.com/html/businesstechnology/2002936638_hddvd18.html
 
B

bleonard24

Audiophyte
Wow, talk about timing! That article pretty much covered everything I wanted to know. I didn't realize this was going to be a VHS/Beta Max-type thing with two different, incompatible formats. I'll definitely wait to see how things fall out. (Hopefully, the tide will turn towards Blu-ray. That will be available on the Playstation III and I'm definitely getting one of those - of course, that could take years to be released.)

For now, I think that means I need to look for a regular DVD player with upconverting.

Any suggestions on good models in that category?

Thanks, Brian! I appreciate the help.
 
brian32672

brian32672

Banned
Well, I got the HVD-2085.
It did not get a great write up here at Audioholics, but I think it works great and it has gotten good write ups/reviews in other places.
I have had dozens of players, and this is the second (rather third) generation of this player.
I also had the player just before this, the 2081.
Link for that player (2085) HERE

One of the more popular players is the Oppo. I recommended it to one fellow, who was not 100% thrilled with it, but the majority of buyers do have good things to say on it.
Link for Oppo HERE

Both are upconverting players and both are rather inexpensive (199.00) way to go until HD-DVD or BLU-Ray are decided on.

(EDIT) Now that I think about it, you may be better with the 2085, because it has HDMI.
The Oppo is DVI
But that is up to you, as you can get a adapter.

The main reason I have gone with the N-N's / is because I also like the VGA out on the 2081/2085
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top