Component does 1080p, but most players will not ouput 1080p over component either native or upscaled. If 1080i/720p is good enough for him, then component is fine. I am in the same situation with my dad right now - he is putting the TV over the fireplace and doesn't want any visible cables, but he wants to make use of the 1080p capability of the TV, so HDMI it is. Plus, one HDMI to the set is easier to run than component + audio.