Grill on or grill off?

How do you use your speakers?

  • My speakers don't have removable grills.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    59
T

Tubes4Life

Junior Audioholic
Do you enjoy your speakers more with the grill covering is on, or when it's off?

Meh, I like them off, because I think they sound better, and because they look sexier when you can see the drivers.
 
Sheep

Sheep

Audioholic Warlord
for me....It would depend on the speaker. For mine right now I leave them on.

I have a large bare concrete floor, so off is not going to help the sound.

SheepStar
 
MACCA350

MACCA350

Audioholic Chief
I leave them on, not for sound or aesthetics but because we have 3 kids and 3 cats who would have a field day with the drivers if the grills were off:eek:

Even if we didn't have kids or cats I think I'd leave em on purely for protection.

There are some speakers like the Paradigm Monitors that actually are built so that they sound better with the grills on, as the grills become an extension of the tweeter surround. Here's an excerpt from Secrets review of them:

Grille or Baffle?

When I first pulled the grille off to admire the drivers, I noticed a funny thing. The tweeter is set into its own plate. That’s not strange at all, but what was strange is that the tweeter's plate, though inset to fit flush at its edges of the cabinet, did not itself present a flush surface to the tweeter diaphragm, raising concerns of diffraction. Why would someone take the time and effort to mount the plate flush with the surface, but not provide a smooth surface on the plate itself? I shrugged, put the grille back on, and went on to listening without worrying, taking note, though, that if the non-flush surface were causing diffraction artifacts, that would screw with imaging and frequency response, the speaker didn’t seem to be suffering a whole lot. Later on, when I got around to taking snapshots, I noticed a very curious thing. The grille itself forms a surface which directly meets the raised edge of the tweeter plate, the surface at the same angle, becoming an extension of that plate just as if it were mounted flush with the entire baffle, with the added benefit of then gradually rolling back to flat, like a gentle horn, so that less treble energy actually hits the corners of the cabinets, limiting diffraction again! Ingenious! I’ve seen it before, specifically in my gone but not forgotten Infinity Renaissance 90s, but occasions have been rare.
 
X

Xsound

Full Audioholic
When I'm at home alone, the grills are off. When the family is around they are on. I prefer them off.
 
cam

cam

Audioholic
MACCA350 said:
I leave them on, not for sound or aesthetics but because we have 3 kids and 3 cats who would have a field day with the drivers if the grills were off:eek:

Even if we didn't have kids or cats I think I'd leave em on purely for protection.

There are some speakers like the Paradigm Monitors that actually are built so that they sound better with the grills on, as the grills become an extension of the tweeter surround. Here's an excerpt from Secrets review of them:
The monitor V3's and the new v4's do not need the grills on. The older ones such as the v1's and models prior needed the grill on since the grill was built to be an extension to the tweeter itself. Paradigm has long since abandoned this design.
 
Nomo

Nomo

Audioholic Samurai
Grill on. The slight improvement in sound wouldn't offset the sound of my girlfriend telling how terrible they look.;)
 
supervij

supervij

Audioholic General
I prefer my speakers with the grill on. I tried them for a couple of days with them off, and I found them very visually distracting. Instead of watching the action on the screen, I found myself glancing over at the speakers too often. I prefer the speakers to be a bit more invisible than that, so I put the grills back on. And frankly, I think they have a much cleaner look with 'em on anyway.

cheers,
supervij
 
shokhead

shokhead

Audioholic General
supervij said:
I prefer my speakers with the grill on. I tried them for a couple of days with them off, and I found them very visually distracting. Instead of watching the action on the screen, I found myself glancing over at the speakers too often. I prefer the speakers to be a bit more invisible than that, so I put the grills back on. And frankly, I think they have a much cleaner look with 'em on anyway.

cheers,
supervij
I'd rather have my wife take her's off and watch her. Grills stay on.
 
j_garcia

j_garcia

Audioholic Jedi
For critical listening, I take the grilles off. The rest of the time they stay on. It's really a matter of personal taste.
 

Buckle-meister

Audioholic Field Marshall
supervij said:
I prefer my speakers with the grill on. I tried them for a couple of days with them off, and I found them very visually distracting. Instead of watching the action on the screen, I found myself glancing over at the speakers too often. I prefer the speakers to be a bit more invisible than that, so I put the grills back on. And frankly, I think they have a much cleaner look with 'em on anyway.
I wholeheartedly agree, though it's not so much with film than music that I find the speakers without their grills off distracting.

Regards
 
Rob Babcock

Rob Babcock

Moderator
In my HT rig the grills are on. My speakers are black but with silver drivers- in my very dark HT room the white drivers are very distracting. In my stereo rig I have the grills off.
 
STRONGBADF1

STRONGBADF1

Audioholic Spartan
Grills on.

As was said before...kid(1), cats(2), dogs(2)...they need protection!
(ya know the Great Dane could do alot of damage just by accident!:eek: )

Besides, my wife (1, thank goodness:rolleyes: ) would be asking me, "What are you doing that for?" all the time.

They sound a better with them off but thats not a blind test opinion. Could just be the cool factor.
 
S

so_cal_forever

Audioholic Intern
The grills included are too thick, so I leave them off for clearer sound.
 
shokhead

shokhead

Audioholic General
so_cal_forever said:
The grills included are too thick, so I leave them off for clearer sound.
Why do you suppose they made such thick grill covers that it effects the sound? Seems thats something they would'nt want to do.
 
majorloser

majorloser

Moderator
I leave my grills on. My speakers are a little unusual. They are Cantons. Canton uses a perforated metal grill and covers the cabinet behind the grill with black velvet. They look nice without the grills but don't want to store them or damage them since they can get dented easily.
 
C

claudermilk

Full Audioholic
Grills on. I tried the speakers both ways after I got them and also found the grills off option to be distracting. I also did not hear any sound improvement (though the room is nowhere near optimal or optimized & probably never will be). Paradigm says they are designed to be on & that's fine with me; it's a cleaner look & improves the WAF anyway.
 
Shadow_Ferret

Shadow_Ferret

Audioholic Chief
I'm wondering if in a blind test you guys could even tell the difference in sound between grill on or grill off. I'd be surprised if you could and then I'd shake your hand. :)

Most grills are transparent acoustically.

I don't even know if I could tell the difference and I have old school wood latice grills on my speakers.

And they've lasted 27 years with them on, so that speaks how well they protect the drivers, methinks.
 
G

GregBe

Audioholic
I leave mine on, but my speakers were designed for them to stay on. My tweeter is offset, and slightly angled away from the listening position. The curved mesh grills offset that angled tweeter, so mine stay on.
 
T

Tubes4Life

Junior Audioholic
I agree with everyone here that using the speakers without the grills can be very distracting. In my HT setup the grills are on, but in my main listeneng area (pets forbidden there) I like the grills off. And in my bedroom, with the speakers I built, I didnt worry about having grill cloth.

Also I am a cat owner, so with that in mind I designed my speakers so the woofer was 24" off the ground. Pets can be very distructive...
 
newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top