ERA D4 by Signal Path International (makers of Musical Fidelity)

Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
Today I had a chance to visit one of the local hi-fi retailers, which is more of an installer than a retailer, but they still have products and demos in their rather small store. They carry a very limited selection of speaker brands, but they seem to have almost all of B&W's speakers in stock aside from the Nautilus (snail speakers) and the Signature Diamond. They have Triad, which is great for in-wall, in-ceiling, hi-fi installs and most recently started carrying ERA.


ERA D4 Satellites

These gems, they could be easily mistaken for real gems, where sitting in the demo room with the speakers I came to addition. I had come to audition the B&W 705s, but we will get to that later. The dealer didn't even give me time to ask about the new speakers (and I was moments from doing so), he says, "you have to hear these new ERA speakers, they are amazing", well that is loosely what he said. I gave them the knocking test, dead as dead gets for a ported speaker.The dealer was right about the sound, they sounded great. This was a rather poorly setup system in a much less than perfect room, but that did not hold the ERA D4 speakers back. The bass was amazing for such small speakers, I can think of no better way to describe the sound other than amazing overall, but the bass from these speakers was eerily good. It wasn't good enough for me to ask "where's the sub", but it was good enough for me to feel all warm and fuzzy inside. If I had to briefly describe the sound of these speakers, I would say "warm and fuzzy". T

We listened to Fiona Apple's release Tidal. The tracks we primarily listened to where "Slow Like Honey", which has some good strong bass notes, and "Pale September" which as some lower xylophone notes. The D4s exhibit the best bass I have ever heard from a 4" driver in any speaker, which is strange to say, seeing how most higher end speakers don't use such small drivers, especially the better known manufacturers. I decided to toe them in for a test of center staging ability and they do center well as well as produce depth and width quite well. I found this to be impressive given the shoddy demo room and overall setup, speakers on shelves. These speakers would likely sound their best placed fairly close to a wall to strengthen the lower notes (ERA's website says the are tuned to 10hz so placing near a wall shouldn't produce boominess). The mid-bass performance was also excellent, xylophones in "Pale September flowed naturally and beautifully. The mid-range and uppers where quite smooth and maintained the grace of the recording without breaking up at higher levels. The dealer tells me the tweeter is way overbuilt for such a speaker, as well as the mid-bass which is high excursion with a very nice rubber surround, sturdy, but not to stiff.

We also tried Heart title from the 80's Little Queen. The track "Love Alive" is very dynamic and has very detailed strings that can be a good indicator how good a speaker really is. Switching between the ERA D4s and B&W 704s didn't reveal how different these speakers are. We all know they are going to be different, and as well they should, the 704s are much more expensive and a larger speaker and should reveal more detail. The ERAs did a good job with details considering their size and also conveyed the dynamics of the track quite well, again considering their small stature.

These speakers should hardly be called "satellites". Sure they are small, but they pack a wallop. The D4 is spec'd to get as low as 58 hz, impressive for a 4" driver. You pair these with a good subwoofer of equal quality and you could have a very nice looking and sounding system, so get out of the way Bose these babies have it all. The only thing they need now is a blessed marketing team and simple to use and setup components.

The ERA D4 retails somewhere from $500-600 for the pair, so if small, but graceful speakers is your thing this might be your bag. Each series (D3, D4, and D5) has a matching LCR speaker and they also offer matching subwoofers. They have a 200 watt class a/b 8" downfiring subwoofer as well as a 300 watt class a/b 10" downfiring subwoofer. All speakers are timbre matched aside from the D3 series, which appears to use a slightly different tweeter, but uses the same topology. The finishes I observed in the store (Sycamore and Cherry) where real wood veneer. Here is a word of warning for potential buyers of this product. The reason this manufacturer is able to put such big sound into these speakers is based on the drivers. There is always a sacrifice with any audio purchase, big or small. The dent you take here is an extremely inefficient and difficult loading speaker. If you want efficient speakers you are going to end up with a big cabinet.


ERA D3 Satellites

I am now considering the lower model D3, pictured directly above, because I like the looks and size of this model more, as well as the price. Those would pair off well with the Teac CD/Receiver I reviewed a month or so ago (review shown in signature).
 
D

Dolby CP-200

Banned
Nicely said now all you need to do is see how well they will compare to a larger room, or do plan to use them for something other than home cinema, a 4” bass mid, that is surprising but only a small portion of the low end will be effectively reproduced within the technical restraints of the loudspeakers design.

Oh one more thing do they have easy bi-wirable binding posts on the back?:)
 
Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
Nicely said now all you need to do is see how well they will compare to a larger room, or do plan to use them for something other than home cinema, a 4” bass mid, that is surprising but only a small portion of the low end will be effectively reproduced within the technical restraints of the loudspeakers design.

Oh one more thing do they have easy bi-wirable binding posts on the back?:)
The room they had the demo in is much larger than my bedroom and they sounded fine. These would not be used in my HT, at least not the first pair. I would rather wait until they make floorstanders to do something like that.

They are not bi-wireable, but if you saw the binding posts on the D3s you would probably unload a brick if you know what a mean. They aren't 5 way, but they are very nice looking, beautiful is the word. Unfortunately the site does not have detailed pictures of these models yet, I hppe they are planning on upgrading that on their site, it would be stupid not to do so.
 
Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
Oh, sorry I forgot to mention this. I wouldn't be to concerned about the small driver. Bedroom configuration would be for easy listening anyway. In an HT configuration they would be set to small with the x-over set to 100hz. They would do a terrific job at producing vocals and most effects, and look great doing it.:)
 
Haoleb

Haoleb

Audioholic Field Marshall
Nice Review, Sounds like your dealer is pretty cool about demoing stuff too. Ive only really been to two true high end places and the first one was great. The salesman knew we werent there to buy anything. And I was only 17 or so at the time so obviously i woudlnt have been able to afford what we heard if i wanted to. (which i did) He demoed a few great systems and took a good hour or so to show us around.

The second place I went to because I was looking for a cd player and they had what I wanted at the time. A NAD C541i, Those guys were real stuck up and unhelpfull.
 
stratman

stratman

Audioholic Ninja
Good review Seth, it left me with a hankerin' to audition the little pups.:D
 
Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
Nice Review, Sounds like your dealer is pretty cool about demoing stuff too. Ive only really been to two true high end places and the first one was great. The salesman knew we werent there to buy anything. And I was only 17 or so at the time so obviously i woudlnt have been able to afford what we heard if i wanted to. (which i did) He demoed a few great systems and took a good hour or so to show us around.

The second place I went to because I was looking for a cd player and they had what I wanted at the time. A NAD C541i, Those guys were real stuck up and unhelpfull.
Yeah, the chain Ovation in our area has some pretty snobish people in it it, I don't like talking it their uneducated stuck up staff. They do have one guy in there that knows his stuff, but you can still tell his nose is slightly elevated.;)

The funny thing is the other store is owned by the son of "SHORT FOR RICHARD!" Freeland ("SHORT FOR RICHARD!" Freeland owns a large majority of Pizza hut's in several states surrounding Indiana). The atmosphere is pretty relaxed and you know that the folks working their know their stuff pretty well. Cables aren't the first thing you see on the way in to their store, which I love, they are actually hidden in a hallway.:D Sometimes when I go in they have a Falcon perched at the front desk, he is tethered of course, but they have a falcon! ("SHORT FOR RICHARD!" Freeland has a license to keep these types of birds and nurse them).

It is a super cool shop, I enjoy stopping in their and talking to the same people that have always been there.:)
 
jaxvon

jaxvon

Audioholic Ninja
Dead as a ported speaker gets? What do you mean by this? A properly damped and braced cabinet should feel and sound like you're knocking on a thick concrete slab.
 
Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
Dead as a ported speaker gets? What do you mean by this? A properly damped and braced cabinet should feel and sound like you're knocking on a thick concrete slab.
Right, and they are. But most ported speakers don't have the dullness that these do when given the knuckle wrap test. I am glad you brought it up because I wasn't certain if I had been the most concise about that in the review.
 
C

cerebrex

Enthusiast
Hopefully I can find a store in my area that will let me listen to these, as I am pretty interested in them.
 
Davemcc

Davemcc

Audioholic Spartan
Seth=L,
I'm glad to see you like the Era. I honestly thought that I've been driving off a weird tangent with my appreciation of the Era. There are not a lot of people here that have auditioned them, although the ones that have seem genuinely impressed with them.

I'd pass on the D3 and wait till you can get the D4. There is a substantial difference in the quality of sound if they will be used as mains. I've ordered a set of D3 for surrounds, but my movie watching is a very small % and I don't need killer surrounds.
 
Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
Davemcc said:
Seth=L,
I'm glad to see you like the Era. I honestly thought that I've been driving off a weird tangent with my appreciation of the Era. There are not a lot of people here that have auditioned them, although the ones that have seem genuinely impressed with them.

I'd pass on the D3 and wait till you can get the D4. There is a substantial difference in the quality of sound if they will be used as mains. I've ordered a set of D3 for surrounds, but my movie watching is a very small % and I don't need killer surrounds.
Oh, I know what you mean about the D3s, but they will be used for a very specific purpose if I do get them. I would be using them with the Teac in a small room with a subwoofer (8" Acoustic Research). I do really like the D4s sound, but I like the way the D3s would look sitting next to the Teac, like a match made in Heaven.:) The wood panels may need upgraded on the Teac to match them, but I do think it should sound and look wonderful.:)
 
Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
Attn. Davemcc,

Oh, sorry, I nearly forgot to ask Dave. How much where the D3s D4s and the D5s? Did you get them online or did you get them in a hi-fi store?

Thank you,

Seth
 
jaxvon

jaxvon

Audioholic Ninja
Right, and they are. But most ported speakers don't have the dullness that these do when given the knuckle wrap test. I am glad you brought it up because I wasn't certain if I had been the most concise about that in the review.
I find that hard to believe. They are only 10.4 lbs. Figuring in driver weight, I just don't see that being enough mass in materials to damp the cabinet to the level that you claim. I'd definitely like to see the insides of their cabinets.

Edit:

I see that Stereophile has recently reviewed them. The cabinet resonance measurement graph is below. This indicates a *highly* resonant cabinet, as I suspected from the low weight. Even worse, the large resonances are in the critical midrange and lower midrange area, the frequency range where it is most important to avoid resonances. I would have to say that the Era cabinets would utterly fail the knuckle rap test.

 
Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
I guess I need to practice my knuckle wrapping.:confused:

They seemed quite dead to me, and they seem quite heavy given their size.
 
jaxvon

jaxvon

Audioholic Ninja
I guess I need to practice my knuckle wrapping.:confused:

They seemed quite dead to me, and they seem quite heavy given their size.
It's not really you. The VAST majority of speaker cabinets are not very dead at all, so perhaps compared to the status quo it seemed pretty dead. If you want to experience a truly dead cabinet, you'll have find a Rockport Antares or somehow knock on WmAx's speakers. Of course, the standards these speakers are built to are insane compared to "normal" speakers.
 
Davemcc

Davemcc

Audioholic Spartan
Seth,
I got the D5 and D3 locally in Canada. D3/4/5 are $500/750/1100 Cdn. I know it's more than in the States, but I like to support local shops to some extent. It can't all be online.

Jaxvon,
The D4 is built from 3/4" MDF and is very small. HWD 9.6" X 5.8" X 6.8". To hold it in your hand, it seems very heavy and sturdy for its size.
 
Seth=L

Seth=L

Audioholic Overlord
It's not really you. The VAST majority of speaker cabinets are not very dead at all, so perhaps compared to the status quo it seemed pretty dead. If you want to experience a truly dead cabinet, you'll have find a Rockport Antares or somehow knock on WmAx's speakers. Of course, the standards these speakers are built to are insane compared to "normal" speakers.
Well, the B&W Nautilus are dead, really sounds like hitting a solid piece of concrete.:)
 

Latest posts

newsletter

  • RBHsound.com
  • BlueJeansCable.com
  • SVS Sound Subwoofers
  • Experience the Martin Logan Montis
Top