Emotiva Ultra Theater Series vs. avr

[wyllisx1]

Is there any reason to go with an avr like the Yamaha RX-V1700 at less that 750.00 instead of the Emotiva combo of LMC-1 LPA-1? Especially since an HMDI 2x1 switcher is included?

This is probably a very noob question, but hey I am a noob.

 

[majorloser]

Both choices are good ones...

Probably the nicest thing about most decent AVR receivers today is they have separate pre-amp outputs for each channel. This allows you to use it as a pre/pro by just adding a separate amplifier. And some AVR receivers will allow you to assign where the on-board amplifiers receive their input signal allowing them to be assigned to the "B" zone. This can allow the on-board amp to power speakers in another room while the separate amplifier(s) power the primary listening zone, "A".

Also, most receivers are adding HDMI switching now.

Might want to also look for a good deal on the Denon 3806. It's received rave reviews from many other sources. Somebody else should hopefully chime in on the Yammie.

Is there an advantage to separates? Now days I'd say "NO". Most receivers have the same features (and more) for at least half the money of a good pre/pro. Granted, Emotiva has brough the prices down to where the average person can afford a basic "separates" system.

(For what it's worth, I have a B&K pre/pro and separate amps. Could have bought Denon's top of the line receiver for what I paid for the pre/pro )

 

[jcPanny]

Seperates

Both the Emotiva Combo and a mid-fi Yamaha/Denon AVR are adequate to drive HT speakers in most rooms. The 63 lb. LPA-1 amp sould have an edge with lower impdance 4 ohm speakers and in larger rooms. Also, a good amp will last a long time. You can get a new pre-pro or receiver with the latest video features without replacing the amp.

The current emotiva pre-pros will not process audio over HDMI like most receivers in the $1k price range but newer models will include this.

 

[wyllisx1]

Thanks
Actually the fact that the Emotiva doesn't process audio over HDMI is a good reason to forgo them then. I don't have an HD tv yet but if I'm going to buy new I'll want to not have to replace anything for awhile.

 

[Nomo]

I recently bought the Emo LPA-1 am currently using the amp section of my Yamaha 1500 to drive only the rear surrounds. While the Emo seems to have a bit more head room, the differences between it and the amp of the yamaha are only slight at normal listening levels.
As far as Emotiva's processors go; I don't care for the fact that they lack internal equalization. I'm not sure how I would deal with that myself.