Normally, it's preferable to have the front three speakers of tha same brand/line in oder to maintain tonal accuracy along the front channels. Can I assume that this new center is a timber matched unit designed for these mains?
In any case, perhaps the old speaker placed more emphasis on certain frequencies than the new speaker does? Maybe you are used to that old, mismatched sound and now that the center matches the mains, it sounds "funny"?
In any case, different speakers sound different and John's efficiency statement is spot on.