Dlp Vs Lcd

[manofsteel2397]

hi im in the market for a new tv i realy like the sony rear projection tv (for the price) but im not sure what is your guys oppions on lcd vs dlp

 

[WorldLeader]

From what I've learned, DLP is better in the front-projection market due to the better blacks and (generally)) non-existant SDE. LCDs usually display more pixilation (SDE), although a notable exception is the Panny au9000, which "softens" the image slightly so no SDE is visible.

In the set-top or rear-projection fields I'm not as knowledgeable, although I will let you in on a little secret: I know a guy who works for TI, and he claims that they have much better DLP chips in R&D that aren't yet being brought to market due to lack of competition. Maybe when Lcos or OLEDS or whatever step up we'll see decreased margins for the manufacturers and much better tech for the consumers.

 

[sholling]

This is one where you need to read tons of reviews and do lots of eyeballs research. And probably buy from a place that has easy returns. I'm in the research phase my self.

Early LCDs and currrent low to mid-priced LCDs suffered from the screen door effect (SDE). Because the pixels were so large and blocky it looked like you were watching through a screen door. With the advent of 1080 LCOS technology SCE is a non-issue. DLP has it's own issues with the rainbow effect caused by the spinning DLP wheel. Some people can see it. The mechanical wear on a wheel spinning at high speed is another issue.

IMO for the next year or two it's personal taste - but be sure to buy 1080P. My crystal ball gets hazy after that but I see LCOS possibly running away with the ball mid-term, and large LCD panels ruling in 10-15 years. But what do I know.

 

[InTheIndustry]

I used to be a big fan of LCD rear projection and disliked DLP rear projection. I have since flip flopped.

LCD struggles with fast motion like a golf ball being hit or football being thrown. The screen door effect on LCD's can be very prevelant during certain types of programming. DLP's black levels tend to be better as well. And, yes, some people can see a rainbow effect in a DLP set. However, that is extremely rare.

I like the new Sony's too (SXRD technology), but typically recommend the DLP's to my customers. They are considerably less money than the SXRD Sony and the picture on them is very very good.

1080P is really only going to be helpful with screens 55" and bigger. That's where you will need the 1080P to see a sharper picture. Smaller than that, I would recommend a 720P or 1080i model because a smaller TV can't display a better picture. I have attended many hours of training with manufactures and manufacturers reps from companies like Vidikron, Samsung, JVC, and several others. The general consensus is 55" and up you will begin to see a difference with 1080P.

Samsung and Toshiba make some really fine DLP TV's that I would recommend. Many people feel that the Sony SXRD models are an excellent choice it's just that I think that just as good can be had for less money.