Describing Loudspeaker Sound

[Buckeyefan 1]

by Alan Lofft, Axiom Audio
www.axiomaudio.com//lofft.html?1055


Describing Loudspeaker Sound

In the course of my work for Axiom, I answer lots of email technical questions on the "sound" of Axiom speakers (as well as that of our competitors' products). One recent email questioner said that he wanted a loudspeaker that embodied the "rich" sound he heard from a live orchestra in a concert hall.

But what did he mean by the adjective "rich"? Did my understanding of "rich" parallel his? Did he mean "rich" as a compliment? (Amongst us picky reviewers, "rich" can sometimes be used as negative quality of a speaker.) What if each of us took away entirely different meanings of the same word? Endless confusion and misunderstanding might ensue. So you see the need for a standardized vocabulary used to describe particular qualities of sound from a loudspeaker, both good and bad.

This isn't a new problem, of course, so I tried to determine exactly what he meant by "rich". Turns out that he meant a full, rounded sound with lots of deep, sonorous bass (more adjectives!). I pointed out that while a fine concert hall and a good recording should preserve and even enhance those qualities, a "neutral" and "linear" speaker will also reproduce them (given that the speaker has smooth, extended bass response) but that the speaker shouldn’t by itself confer a "rich" sound on all music played through it. If it did, that "richness" could become a tiresome bass "coloration": it might sound great on some music but not so good on other types. In fact, among reviewers, "rich," "ripe" or "chesty" is often used as a criticism for loudspeakers that have too much upper bass emphasis, which give male voices a "fat" unnatural coloration.

What follows is a list of standard terms that have evolved from years of loudspeaker listening tests in which I participated, conducted at Canada's National Research Council (NRC) acoustics lab. I've taken the list from forms originally compiled by Dr. Floyd Toole during his long tenure at the NRC Acoustics Division for use in subjective double-blind listening tests, as well as additions from my own notes during those tests and those of other long-time reviewers, including Ian G. Masters. The forms and adjectives we used were to solve this very problem, because sometimes reviewers can become almost poetic in their descriptions of loudspeaker sound, as if the speaker were a musical instrument in and of itself! For instance, does a term like "chocolaty midrange" have meaning for anyone other than the writer who used it? Does it mean that the sound is smooth, thick, or dark? And is it a criticism or a compliment? Who knows?

Here are some common terms to describe loudspeaker sound. "Forward" indicates that vocals, male and female, tend to be very present, almost as if the singer were standing in front of the plain of the speakers. It can be a negative term, too--if singers sound too close up it may mean the midrange is boosted or exaggerated. The opposite is "recessed," which means that midrange sounds like singers and choruses seem to be farther back, a bit distant-sounding and well behind the plain of the speakers.

"Spacious" and "open" and "airy," all positive traits, describe the sense of space present around the instruments and singers; it relates to the speaker's presentation of the stereo "soundstage" (the three-dimensional positioning of the instruments across an imaginary stage) in addition to how well it reproduces the ambient sounds present in the original recording. The opposite is "closed," "muted" or "dry," which indicate the midrange and treble are rolled off or depressed and dull.

Words like "sibilant" mean the speaker has a midrange/treble peak that emphasizes the "sss" and "ttt" sounds of singers’ vocals. The same speaker might also be a bit "bright" (a little treble emphasis) or quite "strident" (way too much treble output, making brass and string sound shrill or harsh).

"Thin" means the speaker has little or no bass output, while "boomy" means it has too much bass that dominates its sound. "Punchy" can be quite pleasing and powerful upper bass, like a disco, but no really deep bass. "Muddy" or "muddled" means the midrange isn't clear; that it's hard to separate the distinct contributions of male and female singers in a chorus.

If a speaker has real problems in the midrange, either a big "suck-out" or valley or other uneven response, terms like "boxy" (vocals sound as if the singer were inside a box) or "honky" are useful. Another common coloration is "nasal," which describes what a midrange peak does to vocals, like what happens to your voice when you cup your hands around your mouth while you're speaking.

Now that you are armed with the right descriptors, you can analyze the sound you hear from speakers in a store demo, at a friend's house (be careful with words like "honky" or "boxy" around friends!) or from your own loudspeakers. Go ahead, try these terms out on our message boards!

 

[Shadow_Ferret]

That is a great article. The speakers, like all your components, should not "color" the music in any way. Neutrality is the ultimate goal. Only the music as originally recorded should be heard without any emphasis or de-emphasis on any frequencies. When I find that speaker, maybe I'll be happy.

That said, all those descriptors are still meaningless without a reference. I would love to sit down with someone who does reviews for a living and listen to speakers as they point out all these little nuances and colorations.

"Here that? That's sibilance. Here that? That's what we mean by spacious."

Because even after nearly 30 years, I still don't critically listen or understand what it is I'm looking for. I still go by my own taste, which might be wrong, or colored by misconception and poor perceptions. I'd like to be educated.

 

[Buckeyefan 1]

Some of these terms kill me

If your buddy comes over and tells you your speakers sound strident, forward, and suffer from suck-out, you should politely ask him to leave. Then proceed to tell your wife your speakers are actually spacious, open, and airy, then give her the visa for the weekend before she leaves you.