Redbone, it sounds like depth is not an issue which means that CRT will blow the crap outta any CRT or plasma out there. 4:3 is not at all the direction you want to head as you already have decided by posting a 16:9 CRT television in your original post.
The world has gone flat panel crazy and quite often doesn't get that CRT is still the standard that no flat panel has come close to reaching yet.
I think if you have been happy with Toshiba, then you will continue to be very happy. Sony is another excellent way to go generally for reliability in quality televisions.
The hard part is maximizing your space with image, so the Toshiba does offer the speakers located under the display which makes it ideal for you. In my opinion, you've already made an excellent choice.